Exploring Mixtures and their Separation
How mixtures are classified and separated: homogeneous and heterogeneous mixtures, solutions and their concentration as a percentage, solubility and solubility curves, crystallisation, distillation, paper chromatography, separating immiscible liquids, sublimation, alloys, suspensions, centrifugation, coagulation, colloids and the Tyndall effect.
Complete answers to every question in this chapter of the NCERT textbook: the questions in Activities 5.1 to 5.9, Think It Over and the questions in the text, the ten Pause and Ponder questions, all fifteen Revise, Reflect, Refine exercises and The Journey Beyond. Each question is given exactly as it appears in the book.
Activities 5.1 to 5.9
Questions in the activities
- Q1Activity 5.1: Let us experiment — Group activity
Are the particles visible in each mixture? Record your observations.Answer
Beaker Mixture Particles visible? A Common salt and water No. The salt dissolves completely; the liquid is clear. B Chalk powder and water Yes. Tiny white chalk particles can be seen; the liquid looks milky. C Milk and water No. The liquid looks uniformly cloudy, but no separate particles can be seen. - Q2Direct the light from a laser pointer through the beakers containing the mixtures (Fig. 5.3) and observe it from the side of the beaker in a direction perpendicular to the laser beam. Record your observations.
Answer
The path of the laser beam is seen in B and C, but not in A. - A (salt solution): the path of the beam is not seen. The dissolved particles are too small to scatter light.
- B (chalk in water): the path of the beam is clearly seen: the chalk particles scatter the light.
- C (milk in water): the path of the beam is seen, although the mixture looks uniform: its particles also scatter the light.
- Q3Predict what you would observe in each of the beakers if you leave them undisturbed for a few minutes.
Answer
- A: no change. The salt stays dissolved.
- B: the chalk particles slowly settle at the bottom and the water above becomes clearer.
- C: no change. The milk particles do not settle.
- Q4Set up a filtration apparatus and filter each mixture separately. Is there any residue left on the filter paper?
Answer
- A: no residue. Dissolved salt passes through the filter paper.
- B: yes, a white residue of chalk stays on the filter paper.
- C: no residue. The milk particles are small enough to pass through.
- Q5Based on your observations, do you think these are the same types of mixtures or are they different?
Answer
They are different types of mixtures:
Beaker Type of mixture Why A Solution Particles invisible, no scattering, no settling, nothing left on the filter B Suspension Particles visible, beam seen, particles settle and are caught by the filter C Colloid Particles invisible and do not settle or filter out, yet the beam is seen - Q6Activity 5.2: Let us represent solubility graphically
Based on the information from the above graph, predict which of the two compounds, ‘A’ or ‘B’, will dissolve more in a given amount of water at a given temperature?Answer
Solubility curves of compounds A and B in water. Compound B. At every temperature its curve is far above that of A: for example, about 241 g of B but only about 45 g of A dissolve in 100 g of water at 40 °C.
- Q7Observe Fig. 5.6 and fill in the blanks of the following statements:(i) The solubility of compound ‘A’ in water at 20 °C is ______________ (less than/more than/similar to) its solubility at 60 °C.(ii) The solubility of compound ‘B’ at 20 °C is ____________ (less than/ more than/similar to) its solubility at 60 °C.(iii) The solubility of ______________ increases more than that of ______________ with an increase in the temperature.
Answer
- (i) less than
- (ii) less than
- (iii) The solubility of compound ‘B’ increases more than that of compound ‘A’: its curve is much steeper.
- Q8What do you think will happen if you make a saturated solution at a higher temperature and cool it slowly?
Answer
As it cools, the solubility falls, so the solution can no longer hold all the solute. The extra solute separates out as crystals. Slow cooling gives larger, well-shaped crystals. This is crystallisation.
- Q9Activity 5.3: Let us prepare
You may also try:1. Place 1 – 2 mL of the saturated copper sulfate solution on a small glass plate or a lamination sheet.2. Leave it for some time. What do you observe?Did you get crystals? If yes, is this a good way to experiment? Explain.Answer
As the water evaporates from the thin layer, small blue crystals of copper sulphate appear on the plate.
It is a quick and easy way to see crystals form and to look at their shapes with a magnifying glass. But it is not a good way to get pure, large crystals: the thin layer dries fast, so the crystals are small and uneven, and any impurity in the drop dries along with them. It also needs care, as copper sulphate is poisonous. For good crystals, cool a filtered hot saturated solution slowly.
- Q10Activity 5.4: Let us describe a process
Observe Fig. 5.9, it shows how salt crystals are obtained from seawater. Can you describe the process in your own words?Answer
- Seawater is let into wide, shallow pans (salt pans) near the coast.
- The heat of the Sun and the wind evaporate the water. The salt left behind makes the solution stronger and stronger until it is saturated.
- As more water evaporates, the extra salt crystallises out as salt crystals.
- The crystals are raked together, collected, washed and purified to give common salt.
- Q11Activity 5.5: Let us investigate
Observe the paper as the water rises through the paper. What do you notice?Answer
The water rises up the paper strip. When it reaches the ink spot, the ink starts to move up with the water and spreads into bands.
- Q12As the water rises, the ink starts to separate into different colour spots. What can you infer from this?
Answer
Black ink separates into dyes of different colours. Black ink is not a single substance: it is a mixture of several dyes. The dyes travel up the paper with the water at different speeds, so they separate into spots at different heights.
- Q13Activity 5.6: Let us separate
Let it stand undisturbed. What do you observe?Answer
The liquids do not mix. They form two separate layers: a yellow layer of mustard oil on top and a colourless layer of water below.
- Q14The yellow-coloured mustard oil forms the upper layer and water forms the lower layer. Can you explain why?
Answer
Mustard oil, the lighter liquid, floats on the denser water. Mustard oil and water are immiscible (they do not mix), and mustard oil is less dense than water. So the oil floats as the upper layer and the denser water sinks to the bottom.
- Q15Activity 5.7: Let us explore
Observe the inner wall of the funnel carefully. Do you notice any solid deposits?Answer
Camphor sublimes and deposits on the cool funnel; sand stays in the dish. Yes. A white solid (camphor) collects on the inner wall of the funnel, while the sand stays in the china dish. On heating, camphor changes directly to vapour (sublimation); the vapour turns straight back into solid on the cool funnel (deposition).
- Q16Activity 5.8: Let us make a model
Make your own centrifuge with a cardboard disc and thick thread. You will be able to see how the heavier particles move outwards. It is a fun and hands-on way to understand the science behind separation. Which mixture would you like to separate using this mini centrifuge?Answer
Making it: thread a long loop of thick string through two holes near the centre of a cardboard disc. Twist the string, then pull and relax the ends again and again so that the disc spins very fast, first one way and then the other. Tape a small, sealed straw or tube containing the mixture along a radius of the disc, closed end outwards.
Mixtures to try: muddy water (the mud collects at the outer, closed end and the water above becomes clearer), or a little chalk or turmeric powder stirred into water. Do not use blood: blood samples must be handled only by trained people.
- Q17Activity 5.9: Complete Table 5.1 and review what you have learnt about solutions, suspensions and colloids.
Answer
S. No. and property Solution Suspension Colloid 1. Nature (homogeneous/heterogeneous) Homogeneous Heterogeneous Heterogeneous (though it looks homogeneous) 2. Particle size Less than 1 nm More than 1000 nm 1 nm to 1000 nm 3. Visibility Particles not visible, even with a microscope Particles visible to the naked eye Particles not visible to the naked eye 4. Separation by filtration Not possible Possible Not possible 5. Settling Does not settle Settles when left undisturbed Does not settle 6. Tyndall effect Not shown Shown Shown
Think It Over and the questions in the text
In-text questions
- Q1Think It Over
Why do suspended particles settle in muddy water over time but not in milk?Answer
Mud particles are large (more than 1000 nm) and heavy, so gravity pulls them to the bottom: muddy water is a suspension.
Milk is a colloid. Its fat and protein particles are much smaller (1 nm to 1000 nm) and stay spread evenly through the water, helped by the milk proteins, which act as emulsifying agents. So they do not settle.
- Q2Think It Over
How is evaporation different from boiling?Answer
Evaporation Boiling Temperature At any temperature, below the boiling point At one fixed temperature, the boiling point Where it happens Only at the surface of the liquid Throughout the liquid; bubbles of vapour form inside it Speed Slow Fast Effect on the liquid Cools the liquid left behind Temperature stays at the boiling point while heat is supplied - Q3Think It Over
Why do you see bright rays of sunlight when it passes through small gaps between the leaves of a dense tree?Answer
The air under the trees holds tiny particles of dust, smoke and water droplets. They scatter the sunlight coming through the gaps, so the path of each beam becomes visible as a bright ray. This is the Tyndall effect.
- Q4Is the mixture of oil and water homogeneous or heterogeneous? Can you think of some other heterogeneous mixtures?
Answer
Oil and water form a heterogeneous mixture: they do not mix and form two layers that can be seen.
Other heterogeneous mixtures: sand and water, muddy water, iron filings and sulphur, sawdust in water, a fruit salad, a mixture of pulses and rice.
- Q5Too little pesticide may not protect crops, while too much can damage crops, soil and the environment. Can you think of other such examples?
Answer
- Medicines: a weak dose may not cure; too strong a dose can harm the patient.
- Saline drips: must be 0.9 % m/v to be safe for blood.
- Chlorine in drinking or pool water: too little leaves germs; too much irritates the eyes and skin.
- Fertiliser solutions: too strong can burn the roots of plants.
- Cooking: sugar syrup for sweets, salt in pickles, and the strength of tea.
- Q6Think as a Scientist
If a hot, saturated solution of copper sulfate is cooled rapidly in ice-cold water, smaller and less well-formed crystals will form than if it is cooled slowly at room temperature. How would you design and perform an experiment to test this hypothesis?Answer
- Make a hot saturated solution of copper sulphate and filter it.
- Pour equal volumes into two identical beakers, P and Q, so that only one thing differs: the rate of cooling.
- Stand P in a bowl of ice-cold water (fast cooling). Leave Q covered at room temperature (slow cooling). Do not disturb either.
- After the same time, collect and dry the crystals. Compare their size and shape with a magnifying glass or ruler.
- Repeat the experiment two or three times to check the result.
If P gives smaller, less regular crystals and Q larger, well-shaped ones, the hypothesis is supported.
- Q7When we allow a solvent to evaporate to get a solute, such as salt from a salt solution, the solvent disappears. However, we may also want to recover the solvent. What should we do then?
Answer
Use distillation. Heat the solution: the solvent turns to vapour, which is cooled in a condenser and collected as a pure liquid. The salt stays behind in the flask.
- Q8While experimenting in the laboratory, a student accidentally mixed acetone and water, two miscible liquids. How can we separate the two miscible liquids? Is it possible to separate the mixture of two miscible liquids by evaporation and obtain both the liquids?
Answer
No. In evaporation the vapour escapes into the air, so the liquid that evaporates is lost; both liquids may also evaporate together.
Acetone (boiling point about 56 °C) and water (100 °C) differ in boiling point by more than 25 °C, so they can be separated by distillation: acetone vaporises first, condenses in the condenser and is collected, while water stays in the flask.
- Q9Similarly, you can separate different pigments present in the green extract of spinach leaves or coloured pigments from the flower petals. Will water work as a solvent in every case?
Answer
No. A solvent can carry only the substances that dissolve in it. Some pigments, such as the green chlorophyll of leaves, hardly dissolve in water, so they do not move up the paper. For these, a different solvent such as alcohol or acetone, or a mixture of solvents, is used.
- Q10Can you think of any heterogeneous mixtures with a gas as one of the components?
Answer
Smoke (solid particles in air), fog and mist (tiny water droplets in air), dust in air, clouds, the foam on a glass of soda or shaving foam (gas bubbles in a liquid), and whipped cream.
- Q11What if …
two immiscible liquids of the same density are mixed in a separating funnel, how will the layers form?Answer
They would not settle into a neat upper and lower layer. With equal densities, neither liquid sinks below the other, so drops or blobs of one liquid would stay floating anywhere in the other. A separating funnel could not then run off one liquid cleanly.
- Q12Similarly, solid carbon dioxide, known as dry ice which is used for ice cream storage, also undergoes sublimation. Can you think of any other mixtures where sublimation can be used to separate the components?
Answer
- Common salt and ammonium chloride (ammonium chloride sublimes).
- Sand and iodine, or salt and iodine (iodine sublimes).
- Naphthalene and sand, or naphthalene and salt.
- Q13Is it possible to dissolve one metal in another?
Answer
Not at room temperature. But when metals are melted, they can mix to form a solution. On cooling, it becomes a solid alloy, a homogeneous mixture, such as brass (copper and zinc) or bronze (copper and tin).
- Q14Can you think of any other coagulation processes used in everyday life?
Answer
- Making paneer (lemon juice or vinegar curdles milk) and curd.
- Blood clotting at a cut.
- Using alum to clear muddy water in homes and water-treatment plants.
- Making tofu from soya milk.
- Q15If the components of blood can be separated by centrifugation and the blood coagulates, is it a suspension? However, we cannot see blood cells with the naked eye. Is it a solution?
Answer
Blood is neither. Its cells cannot be seen with the naked eye and do not settle quickly, so it is not a true suspension; but it scatters light and can be separated by spinning, so it is not a solution. Blood is a colloid.
- Q16Have you ever observed light scattering by particles in your surroundings? … Think of some more examples!
Answer
- A torch or headlight beam on a foggy or dusty night.
- Sunlight coming into a dark room through a small hole or a gap in the curtains.
- The beam from a cinema projector.
- Sunbeams through clouds or through mist in a forest.
- Q17Imagine trying to separate all the ingredients in a lemonade once they have been mixed. Can you do it?
Answer
Not completely. Sugar, salt and lemon juice are all dissolved in water, so filtration cannot remove them. Distillation can recover the water, but sugar and salt are left mixed together, and the lemon flavour is partly lost. Some mixtures are very hard to separate fully.
Pause and Ponder 1 to 10
Pause and Ponder
- Q1A common talcum powder contains 4 % m/m zinc oxide, which acts as an antiseptic. How much zinc oxide is present in 300 g of the talcum powder?
Answer
4 % m/m means 4 g of zinc oxide in every 100 g of powder.
zinc oxide=4100 × 300 g=12 g300 g of talcum powder contains 12 g of zinc oxide.
- Q2Your mother gives you a bottle of orange juice concentrate to mix with water and serve it to your visiting friends. She asks you to mix two tablespoons of the concentrate with water in a glass tumbler. If each tablespoon measures 15 mL and you make 150 mL of juice per person, what is the % v/v of orange juice concentrate in the mixture you prepared?
Answer
concentrate=2 × 15 mL=30 mLpercentage=30 mL150 mL × 100=20 % v/vThe juice is 20 % v/v orange juice concentrate.
- Q3Vinegar, used as a food preservative and additive, contains 5 % v/v acetic acid. Glacial acetic acid is a liquid, i.e., 100% acetic acid. If you want to make vinegar from glacial acetic acid, how would you proceed?
Answer
5 % v/v means 5 mL of acetic acid in every 100 mL of vinegar. So:
- Measure 5 mL of glacial acetic acid in a measuring cylinder.
- Add it to some water in a 100 mL measuring flask or cylinder.
- Add more water until the total volume of the solution is exactly 100 mL, and stir.
For a larger amount, keep the same ratio: 50 mL of glacial acetic acid made up to 1000 mL (1 L). (Glacial acetic acid is corrosive: this should be done by an adult, adding the acid to the water.)
- Q4Refer to the solubility curves given in Activity 5.2. If equal masses of hot, saturated solutions of compounds ‘A’ and ‘B’ are cooled from 80 °C to 60 °C, which solution is likely to deposit more solid?
Answer
The solution of B. From the curves (values per 100 g of water):
Solubility at 80 °C Solubility at 60 °C Solid deposited A about 60 g about 52 g about 8 g B about 343 g 287 g about 56 g B’s solubility falls much more over this range (its curve is steeper), so far more of it comes out as crystals. This stays true when equal masses of the two solutions are compared.
- Q5Will there be any change in the size of common salt crystals if the rate of evaporation is increased or decreased? Explain.
Answer
- Faster evaporation gives smaller crystals: the particles come out of solution quickly and have no time to build large, regular crystals; many small crystals start at once.
- Slower evaporation gives larger, better-shaped crystals: the particles have time to settle neatly onto a few growing crystals.
- Q6State whether the following statements are True or False. Also, correct the False statements.(i) Salt can be separated from a salt solution by evaporation or distillation.(ii) Distillation can be used for separation of two liquids even when these have the same boiling point.(iii) In paper chromatography, the solvent level should be above the sample spot at the beginning of the experiment.(iv) Evaporation and crystallization are the same processes.
Answer
- (i) True. Evaporation leaves the salt; distillation leaves the salt and also recovers the water.
- (ii) False. Distillation can separate two liquids only when their boiling points are different (by about 25 °C or more for simple distillation).
- (iii) False. The solvent level should be below the sample spot; otherwise the sample dissolves into the solvent.
- (iv) False. In evaporation the solvent is removed completely, and all the dissolved substances, including impurities, are left behind. In crystallisation a hot saturated solution is cooled so that pure crystals form, while the impurities stay in the solution.
- Q7Why do immiscible liquids form two separate layers in a separating funnel?
Answer
Immiscible liquids do not mix with each other, and they have different densities. So on standing, the denser liquid sinks to form the lower layer and the lighter liquid floats as the upper layer.
- Q8Is sublimation different from evaporation? Justify.
Answer
Yes.
Sublimation Evaporation Change Solid changes directly to vapour, with no liquid stage Liquid changes to vapour Starts as A solid (such as camphor, naphthalene, dry ice) A liquid (such as water) Used to separate A solid that sublimes from one that does not (camphor and sand) A dissolved solid from its solvent (salt from salt water) - Q9Clouds are made up of tiny water droplets or ice crystals floating in the air. Based on what you know about solutions, suspensions and colloids, what type of mixture do you think clouds are and why?
Answer
Clouds are a colloid (an aerosol: a liquid or solid dispersed in a gas).
- The tiny water droplets or ice crystals are dispersed through the air (the dispersion medium) and stay floating instead of settling quickly.
- They scatter light (the Tyndall effect), which is why clouds look white and sunbeams can be seen through gaps in them.
- They are not a solution, because the droplets are not dissolved in the air. When the droplets grow large and heavy, they fall as rain: the cloud then behaves like a suspension.
- Q10Why do cities with a lot of smoke and dust in the air often look hazy?
Answer
Smoke and dust particles floating in the air scatter the light passing through it (the Tyndall effect). The scattered light makes the air look milky, so distant buildings look blurred: the city looks hazy.
Revise, Reflect, Refine 1 to 15
Exercises
- Q1Which of the following mixtures are correctly classified as homogeneous (Hm) and heterogeneous (Ht)? Choose the correct option.(i) Air — Hm, Milk — Ht, Sugar solution — Hm, Smoke — Hm(ii) Brass — Ht, Fog — Ht, Vinegar — Ht, Muddy water — Hm(iii) Copper sulfate solution — Hm, Salt solution — Hm, Milk — Hm, Bronze — Hm(iv) Muddy water — Ht, Milk — Ht, Blood — Ht, Brass — Hm
Answer
(iv) Muddy water — Ht, Milk — Ht, Blood — Ht, Brass — Hm
- (i) is wrong: smoke is heterogeneous (solid particles in air).
- (ii) is wrong: brass is homogeneous (an alloy), vinegar is homogeneous (a solution) and muddy water is heterogeneous.
- (iii) is wrong: milk is a colloid, a heterogeneous mixture.
- (iv) is right: muddy water is a suspension, milk and blood are colloids, and brass is an alloy, a homogeneous mixture.
- Q2Choose the correct options, and explain the reason for the correct and incorrect options.
Which among the following mixtures show the Tyndall Effect? A mixture of:(a) air and dust particles(b) copper sulfate and water(c) starch and water(d) acetone and water(i) a and b (ii) b and d (iii) a and c (iv) c and dAnswer
(iii) a and c
- (a) Shows it. Dust particles in air are large enough to scatter light (a beam through a dusty room is visible).
- (b) Does not. Copper sulphate dissolves to form a true solution; its particles are too small to scatter light.
- (c) Shows it. Starch in water forms a colloid, whose particles scatter light.
- (d) Does not. Acetone and water mix to form a true solution.
So (i), (ii) and (iv) are wrong because each includes a solution, (b) or (d).
- Q3A mixture can be categorised as a solution, a suspension, or a colloid, each possessing distinct properties. Utilise the words or phrases provided in the box to fill in the Table 5.2. Words and phrases may be used more than once.Words and Phrases: Large-sized particles; Particles remain evenly distributed; Small-sized particles (less than 1 nm diameter); Moderate-sized particles (1 – 1000 nm); Settles down when left undisturbed (more than 1000 nm in diameter); Does not settle down; Scatters light; Separates by filtration; Transparent; Salt solution; Milk; Sand in water; Smoke; Heterogeneous mixture; Cannot be separated by filtration; Mud; Butter; Brass.
Answer
Solution Suspension Colloid Properties Small-sized particles (less than 1 nm diameter); particles remain evenly distributed; does not settle down; transparent; cannot be separated by filtration Large-sized particles; settles down when left undisturbed (more than 1000 nm in diameter); scatters light; separates by filtration; heterogeneous mixture Moderate-sized particles (1 – 1000 nm); particles remain evenly distributed; does not settle down; scatters light; cannot be separated by filtration; heterogeneous mixture Examples Salt solution; brass Sand in water; mud Milk; smoke; butter - Q4Solve the following problems:(i) A cake recipe uses dry ingredients, namely 75 g of sugar for 420 g of all-purpose flour and 5 g of sodium hydrogencarbonate. Express the concentration of each component in the mixture using an appropriate method.(ii) A brass alloy contains 70% copper by mass. Calculate the quantities of copper and zinc present in 120 g of brass.
Answer
(i) All three are solids weighed in grams, so use the mass by mass percentage.
total mass=75 g + 420 g + 5 g=500 gSugar and flour:
sugar=75 g500 g × 100=15 % m/mflour=420 g500 g × 100=84 % m/mSodium hydrogencarbonate:
percentage=5 g500 g × 100=1 % m/mCheck: 15% + 84% + 1% = 100%.
(ii)
mass of copper=70100 × 120 g=84 gmass of zinc=120 g − 84 g=36 g120 g of brass contains 84 g of copper and 36 g of zinc.
- Q5The label on a cooking oil pack says one litre (910 g). If this oil is mixed with water, will it form a separate layer? If so, which substance will be on top? How will you separate the two layers? Also, draw the diagram of the apparatus used.
Answer
density of oil=910 g1000 mL=0.91 g mL−1- Yes, it forms a separate layer: oil and water are immiscible.
- Water has a density of about 1 g mL−1, so the less dense oil is on top.
- Separate them with a separating funnel: let the layers settle, open the stopcock to run off the lower water layer, close it, then collect the oil.
Separating oil from water with a separating funnel. - Q6Assertion (A): Solutions do not exhibit the Tyndall effect.
Reason (R): The particles in solutions are larger than 100 nm, so they cannot scatter light.
Choose the correct option:(i) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.(ii) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.(iii) A is true, but R is false.(iv) A is false, but R is true.Answer
(iii) A is true, but R is false.
Solutions do not show the Tyndall effect, but the reason is that their particles are very small (less than 1 nm), too small to scatter light. Large particles would scatter light.
- Q7How would you separate the mixtures given in Table 5.3? Mention the reason for choosing your method. If a mixture cannot be separated, explain why.
Answer
Mixture Method of separation Reason for selection Mud from muddy water Let it settle and decant, then filter; add alum (coagulation) if it stays cloudy Mud particles are insoluble and heavier; alum makes the fine ones clump and settle Plasma from other components in the blood sample Centrifugation Blood cells are heavier than plasma and are thrown to the bottom when spun Naphthalene and sand Sublimation Naphthalene sublimes on heating; sand does not Chalk powder and common salt Dissolve in water, filter, then evaporate the filtrate Salt dissolves, chalk does not: chalk stays on the filter paper; evaporation gives back the salt Common salt and water Evaporation (or distillation to keep the water too) Water turns to vapour, salt does not Oil from water Separating funnel The liquids are immiscible and have different densities Pigments of the flower Paper chromatography The pigments move up the paper at different speeds with the solvent - Q8Two miscible liquids, A and B, are present in a mixture. The boiling point of A is 60 °C and the boiling point of B is 90 °C. Suggest a method to separate them. Also, draw a labelled diagram of the method suggested.
Answer
The boiling points differ by 90 °C − 60 °C = 30 °C, which is more than 25 °C, so use simple distillation.
- Heat the mixture gently in a distillation flask. A, with the lower boiling point, vaporises first (the thermometer reads about 60 °C).
- The vapour of A is cooled in the water condenser and collected as liquid A in the conical flask.
- B remains in the distillation flask.
Separating liquids A and B by distillation. - Q9Compare evaporation, crystallization and distillation. In which situation, would you prefer each of these over the others?
Answer
Evaporation Crystallisation Distillation What happens The solvent is heated and escapes as vapour A hot saturated solution is cooled; pure crystals form The liquid is boiled; its vapour is condensed and collected What you get The solid only (solvent lost) Pure solid crystals The pure liquid (and the solid left behind) Purity of solid Impurities stay mixed in High: impurities stay in solution Not used for purifying the solid Prefer it when You only need the dissolved solid and purity does not matter (salt from seawater) You need a pure solid (pure copper sulphate or sugar) You need to recover the liquid (pure water from salt water) or to separate miscible liquids (acetone from water) - Q10Blood is an example of a colloidal mixture. (i) What would happen if blood behaved like a true suspension inside the body? (ii) In a blood sample, identify the dispersed phase and the dispersion medium.
Answer
(i) In a suspension the particles settle when left undisturbed. The blood cells would sink and collect in the lower parts of the blood vessels and body, and the blood would separate into layers. Oxygen and nutrients would not be carried evenly to all parts, and the settled cells could block blood vessels. This would be very harmful.
(ii) Dispersed phase: the blood cells (red and white blood cells) and platelets, together with large protein particles. Dispersion medium: the plasma, a watery liquid.
- Q11You are given a mixture of sand, common salt and naphthalene (Fig. 5.25a). The Fig. 5.25b depicts various steps used to separate the components of this mixture. Identify and write down the correct sequence of separation techniques.
Answer
1 → 3 → 2
- Step 1, sublimation: heat the mixture in a china dish under an inverted funnel. Naphthalene sublimes and collects on the funnel; sand and salt stay in the dish.
- Step 3, filtration: add water to the sand and salt and stir. Salt dissolves; filter, and sand stays on the filter paper.
- Step 2, evaporation: heat the filtrate (salt solution) in a china dish until the water evaporates, leaving the salt.
Sublimation must come first: once water is added, naphthalene would be wet and mixed with the sand.
- Q12Why is distillation an effective method for separating a mixture of water and acetone?
Answer
Acetone and water are miscible, so they cannot be separated by a separating funnel or filtration. But their boiling points are very different: acetone about 56 °C and water 100 °C, a difference of 44 °C (more than 25 °C). On heating, acetone vaporises first, almost before any water vapour forms. Its vapour is condensed and collected, leaving water in the flask.
- Q13Answer the following questions with the help of the data given in Table 5.4.(i) What mass of potassium nitrate would be needed to prepare its saturated solution in 50 g of water at 40 °C?(ii) A student makes a saturated solution of potassium chloride in water at 80 °C and leaves the solution to cool at room temperature (25 °C). What would she observe as the solution cools? Explain.(iii) What is the effect of a change in temperature on the solubility of salts? Also, compare the changes in the solubility of the four given salts with increasing temperature from 10 °C to 80 °C.
Salts 10 °C 20 °C 30 °C 40 °C 60 °C 80 °C Potassium nitrate 21 32 45 62 106 167 Sodium chloride 36 36 36.3 36.5 37 37 Potassium chloride 35 35 37.4 40 46 54 Ammonium chloride 24 37 41 41 55 66 Answer
(i) At 40 °C, 62 g of potassium nitrate saturates 100 g of water.
mass needed=62 g100 g × 50 g=31 g(ii) She would see crystals of potassium chloride forming. Its solubility falls from 54 g per 100 g of water at 80 °C to about 36 g at 25 °C (between 35 g at 20 °C and 37.4 g at 30 °C). The solution cannot hold the extra salt, so about 54 g − 36 g = 18 g crystallises out for every 100 g of water.
(iii) For all four salts, solubility increases as temperature rises, but by very different amounts:
Salt 10 °C 80 °C Increase Change Potassium nitrate 21 g 167 g 146 g Largest, very steep rise Ammonium chloride 24 g 66 g 42 g Large rise Potassium chloride 35 g 54 g 19 g Moderate rise Sodium chloride 36 g 37 g 1 g Almost no change So crystallisation by cooling works well for potassium nitrate but hardly at all for sodium chloride, which is why common salt is obtained by evaporation.
- Q14Three students, A, B and C, are preparing sugar solutions for an experiment:• Student A dissolves 20 g of sugar in 80 g of water.• Student B dissolves 20 g of sugar in 100 g of water.• Student C dissolves 30 g of sugar in 80 g of water.(i) Calculate the mass percentage (% m/m) concentration of sugar in each student’s solution.(ii) Whose solution is the most concentrated? Explain why.
Answer
A=20 g20 g + 80 g × 100=20 % m/mB=20 g20 g + 100 g × 100=20 g120 g × 100≈16.7 % m/mC=30 g30 g + 80 g × 100=30 g110 g × 100≈27.3 % m/m(ii) Student C’s solution is the most concentrated: it has the largest mass of sugar in every 100 g of solution (about 27.3 g, compared with 20 g for A and 16.7 g for B).
- Q15Examine Fig. 5.26.(i) Identify the separation technique marked as ‘S’.(ii) Label the apparatus A, B and C.(iii) Which of the following mixtures can be separated by the technique identified above? Use the data given in Table 5.5. Mixtures:(a) water — acetone (b) water — salt (c) acetone — alcohol (d) sand — salt (e) alcohol — chloroform (f) alcohol — benzeneTable 5.5: Boiling points: Water 100 °C, Acetone 56 °C, Alcohol 78 °C, Chloroform 61 °C, Benzene 80 °C
Answer
(i) S is distillation.
(ii) A: distillation flask (with the mixture); B: water condenser; C: conical flask (receiver) collecting the distillate.
Mixture Difference in boiling point Separated by distillation? (a) water — acetone 100 °C − 56 °C = 44 °C Yes (b) water — salt Salt does not boil; water does Yes: water distils, salt stays (c) acetone — alcohol 78 °C − 56 °C = 22 °C No (less than 25 °C: needs fractional distillation) (d) sand — salt Both solids No (dissolve, filter and evaporate) (e) alcohol — chloroform 78 °C − 61 °C = 17 °C No (less than 25 °C) (f) alcohol — benzene 80 °C − 78 °C = 2 °C No So (a) and (b) can be separated by simple distillation.
The Journey Beyond
The Journey Beyond
- Q1Demonstrate the Tyndall effect using different colloids. Create a series of experiments showcasing how light scatters in colloids making the beam visible. Use laser pointers (Safety first: Use it under the supervision of an adult), flashlights, or other light sources for your demonstrations.
Answer
Set up a row of clear glasses: plain water, salt water, sugar water, a few drops of milk in water, starch water (a pinch of cornflour boiled in water), diluted soap solution, and water with a drop of ink. In a dark room, shine a torch or laser through each from the side.
The beam is not seen in water, salt water, sugar water or ink water (solutions), but it is seen in milk, starch and soap water (colloids). You can also spray a mist of water or light an incense stick near the beam in air.
- Q2Make crystals of different compounds (common salt, epsom salt, sugar, borax, nickel sulfate, etc.). Observe them under a magnifying glass or a microscope. Note down their colours and shapes.
Answer
Make a hot saturated solution of each, filter it and let it cool slowly in a clean jar (a thread hung in the jar gives crystals somewhere to grow). What you can expect:
Compound Colour Shape Common salt Colourless or white Cubes Epsom salt Colourless Long, thin needles Sugar Colourless Slanting, box-like prisms Borax Colourless or white Short, many-sided prisms Nickel sulphate Green Square-based prisms Nickel sulphate is poisonous; handle it only with an adult’s help and wear gloves.
- Q3Do red leaves also contain green pigments? Investigate it using paper chromatography.
Answer
Crush red leaves with a little alcohol (or acetone) to get a coloured extract and spot it repeatedly on a pencil line on a chromatography strip; run it with alcohol as the solvent. Usually the red leaf extract separates into a green band (chlorophyll) as well as red and yellow bands. So red leaves often do contain green pigment, hidden by the red pigment.
- Q4You can try chromatography to find the number of components present in a food colour (green, orange, yellow, etc.) or in coloured mouth fresheners (fennel seeds).
Answer
Soak a few coloured fennel seeds in a drop of water and spot the colour on a strip; do the same for each food colour. Use water or 2 % m/v salt solution as the solvent. Count the separate spots: one spot means a single dye; two or more mean a mixture (green food colour, for example, often separates into blue and yellow).
- Q5Design an educational game where players identify and apply separation techniques to different mixtures through interactive challenges and hands-on activities.
Answer
One idea: make cards, each naming a mixture (camphor and sand, oil and water, ink, muddy water, seawater). Players draw a card and must name the method and the property it uses within 30 seconds, then try a safe, simple version of it at a “lab station”. Score points for correct answers. The Activity tab for this chapter has games of this kind.
- Q6If you are camping outdoors and running short on clean water, you can obtain clean water by distillation. Can you think of a set-up with the items available to you?
Answer
A simple still: heat the dirty water in a large pot over a fire. Place a small clean bowl in the middle of the pot (on a stone so that it stands above the water). Cover the pot with its lid turned upside down, and put cold water or ice on the lid. Steam rises, condenses on the cold lid, runs down to the lowest point and drips into the bowl as clean water.
A solar still works without fire: dig a hole, put a cup in the centre, cover with a plastic sheet held down by stones at the edges, and put a small stone on the sheet above the cup. The Sun evaporates water from the ground and the droplets that condense under the sheet drip into the cup.
- Q7The Quest Continues …
Can we create artificial blood that works just as real blood for all patients?Answer
Not yet. Scientists are developing blood substitutes that can carry oxygen, and red blood cells grown in laboratories from stem cells. But real blood does many jobs at once: carrying oxygen, fighting infection, clotting and carrying nutrients and hormones. No artificial product does all of these safely for every patient yet, so blood donation is still essential.