Chapter 5 · Chemistry

Exploring Mixtures and their Separation

How mixtures are classified and separated: homogeneous and heterogeneous mixtures, solutions and their concentration as a percentage, solubility and solubility curves, crystallisation, distillation, paper chromatography, separating immiscible liquids, sublimation, alloys, suspensions, centrifugation, coagulation, colloids and the Tyndall effect.

Revising? See the three percentage formulas on one page, and play the separation games.
In this chapter 12 topics
  1. 1Homogeneous and heterogeneous mixtures
  2. 2Solutions and concentration
  3. 3Concentration as a percentage
  4. 4Solubility and solubility curves
  5. 5Crystallisation
  6. 6Distillation and fractional distillation
  7. 7Paper chromatography
  8. 8Separating immiscible liquids
  9. 9Sublimation, and alloys
  10. 10Suspensions, centrifugation and coagulation
  11. 11Colloids and the Tyndall effect
  12. 12Choosing a separation method

1Homogeneous and heterogeneous mixtures

Mixture

Two or more substances mixed together, each keeping its own properties. A mixture can usually be separated by physical methods.

Homogeneous mixtureHeterogeneous mixture
CompositionThe same throughoutNot the same throughout
Can you see the parts?NoOften yes
ExamplesSugar in water, vinegar (acetic acid in water), soda water (carbon dioxide in water), airSand in water, oil and water, muddy water, iron filings and sulphur
  • A homogeneous mixture is also called a solution. A well-stirred sugar solution is equally sweet in the first sip and the last.
  • Mixtures are also grouped by the size of their particles into solutions, suspensions and colloids (see topics 10 and 11).

Activity 5.1: three mixtures, one laser beam

Salt in water (A), chalk powder in water (B) and a few drops of milk in water (C) are each stirred, lit from the side with a laser pointer, left to stand and then filtered.

A laser beam passes through three beakers. In A, a salt solution, the path of the beam cannot be seen. In B, chalk powder in water, and in C, a little milk in water, the particles scatter the light and the path of the beam can be seen.ASalt solutionBeam not seenBChalk in waterBeam seenCMilk in waterBeam seen
Figure 1. A laser beam through three mixtures. Its path shows up only where particles scatter the light.
A: salt and waterB: chalk and waterC: milk and water
Particles visible?NoYesNo (looks cloudy)
Path of the beamNot seenSeenSeen
After standing a few minutesNo changeChalk settles at the bottomNo settling
Residue on filter paperNoneChalkNone
Type of mixtureSolutionSuspensionColloid

Safety first

Never look into a laser beam or point it at anyone’s eyes. It can damage the eyes for ever.

Remember

  • Homogeneous: the same composition throughout (a solution). Heterogeneous: not the same throughout.
  • Three mixtures that look alike can behave very differently with light, on standing and on filtering.
Quick checkIs a mixture of oil and water homogeneous or heterogeneous?Show answer

Heterogeneous. Oil and water do not mix; they form two separate layers that you can see.

2Solutions and concentration

Solute and solvent

In a solution, the solute is the substance that dissolves and the solvent is the substance it dissolves in. In sugar water, sugar is the solute and water is the solvent.

Concentration

The amount of solute present in a given amount of solvent or solution.

  • The right proportion matters. Oral Rehydration Solution (ORS) has fixed amounts of salt and sugar in a fixed volume of water. Change them and it is no longer ORS. (Not every sugary drink is ORS.)
  • A pesticide spray that is too weak does not protect crops; one that is too strong harms crops, soil and the environment.
  • Concentration matters in medicines, farming, food, cosmetics, and even in a cup of tea.

Meet a scientist

Dr Dilip Mahalanabis, an Indian paediatrician, developed and used ORS to treat dehydration caused by diarrhoea and cholera. Oral rehydration therapy has saved millions of lives since the World Health Organization spread its use worldwide.

Remember

  • Solution = solute + solvent.
  • Concentration tells how much solute is in a given amount of solvent or solution.
Quick checkIn salt water, which is the solute and which is the solvent?Show answer

Salt is the solute (it dissolves); water is the solvent.

3Concentration as a percentage

Packets and bottles often give concentration as a percentage. There are three common kinds.

A. Mass by mass percentage (% m/m or % w/w)

mass by mass percentage = mass of solutemass of solution × 100

  • Grams of solute in 100 g of solution.
  • Mass of solution = mass of solute + mass of solvent.
  • Also used for heterogeneous mixtures such as milk powder and spice mixes, and on food labels (salt, sugar, protein per 100 g).

Worked example 1

A salt solution is made by dissolving 15 g of salt in 135 g of water. Find its mass by mass percentage.

Given
mass of salt = 15 gmass of water = 135 g
Find
mass by mass percentage

Solution

mass of solution=15 g + 135 g=150 gpercentage=15 g150 g × 100=10 % m/m

The solution is 10 % m/m.

B. Mass by volume percentage (% m/v)

mass by volume percentage = mass of solutevolume of solution × 100

  • Grams of solute in 100 mL of solution.
  • Used where measuring a volume is easier than weighing, as in hospitals and laboratories: a 5 % m/v glucose drip has 5 g of glucose in every 100 mL.
  • A saline drip is usually 0.9 % m/v sodium chloride: 0.9 g of salt in every 100 mL. This strength is safe for blood and replaces lost body fluids.

Worked example 2

A nurse dissolves 2 g of glucose in water to make 40 mL of solution. Find its concentration.

Given
mass of glucose = 2 gvolume of solution = 40 mL
Find
mass by volume percentage

Solution

percentage=2 g40 mL × 100=5 % m/v

The solution is 5 % m/v.

C. Volume by volume percentage (% v/v)

volume by volume percentage = volume of solutevolume of solution × 100

  • Millilitres of solute in 100 mL of solution.
  • Used when two liquids that mix are put together: perfumes, cosmetics, vinegar (5 % v/v acetic acid).

Worked example 3

A cleaning liquid is made by mixing 30 mL of a concentrate with water to give 600 mL of solution. Find its concentration.

Given
volume of concentrate = 30 mLvolume of solution = 600 mL
Find
volume by volume percentage

Solution

percentage=30 mL600 mL × 100=5 % v/v

The cleaning liquid is 5 % v/v.

Mass or weight?

Industry often uses weight by weight percentage (% w/w). In everyday use weight and mass are used interchangeably, so % m/m and % w/w have the same value.

Finding the mass of solute

Turn the formula round: mass of solute = percentage100 × mass of solution.

For example, the salt in 250 g of a 4 % m/m solution:

mass of salt=4100 × 250 g=10 g

Remember

  • % m/m: grams of solute per 100 g of solution.
  • % m/v: grams of solute per 100 mL of solution.
  • % v/v: millilitres of solute per 100 mL of solution.
  • Always divide by the solution (solute + solvent), not by the solvent alone.
Quick check20 g of sugar is dissolved in 80 g of water. What is the % m/m of sugar?Show answer
percentage=20 g20 g + 80 g × 100=20 g100 g × 100=20 % m/m

4Solubility and solubility curves

Solubility

The largest amount of solute that can dissolve in a fixed amount of solvent (usually 100 g of water) at a given temperature.

Saturated solution

A solution that cannot dissolve any more solute at that temperature.

Solids in liquidsGases in liquids
As the temperature rises, solubility usuallyIncreasesDecreases
ExampleMore sugar dissolves in hot tea than in coldA warm fizzy drink goes flat sooner: less carbon dioxide stays dissolved

Activity 5.2: solubility curves

Solubility curve

A graph of solubility (on the y-axis) against temperature (on the x-axis).

Solubility curves of two compounds in water. The solubility of compound B is much larger and rises steeply with temperature: 241 g per 100 g of water at 40 °C and 287 g at 60 °C. Compound A dissolves much less, about 30 g to 60 g per 100 g of water, and its solubility rises only slowly.01020304050607080050100150200250300350400241 g287 gCompound BCompound ATemperature (°C)Solubility (g per 100 g of water)
Figure 2. Solubility curves of compounds A and B in water. Dashed lines read off the solubility of B at 40 °C and 60 °C.
  • At every temperature, more of B dissolves than of A.
  • The solubility of A at 20 °C is less than at 60 °C; so is the solubility of B.
  • The solubility of B increases more than that of A as the temperature rises: its curve is much steeper.

Remember

  • Solubility depends on temperature, so always state the temperature.
  • Solids usually dissolve more in hot water; gases dissolve less.
  • A steep solubility curve means solubility changes a lot with temperature.
Quick checkUsing Figure 2, find the solubility of B at 40 °C.Show answer

About 241 g per 100 g of water.

5Crystallisation

Crystal

A solid made of particles arranged in a regular, repeating pattern. Examples: rock salt, sugar crystals (mishri), snowflakes, frost.

Crystallisation

Forming pure crystals from a hot saturated solution by letting it cool.

How it works

A saturated solution of B at 60 °C holds 287 g in 100 g of water. At 40 °C only 241 g can stay dissolved, so the rest comes out as crystals. For every 100 g of water:

mass of crystals=287 g − 241 g=46 g
  • Crystallisation works because solubility changes with temperature.
  • It is used to purify a solid and to separate two soluble solids when one is present in only a small amount: the impurity stays dissolved.

Activity 5.3: crystals of copper sulphate

Four steps of crystallisation. 1: copper sulphate is dissolved in water in a beaker heated in a water bath until the solution is saturated. 2: the hot solution is filtered to remove insoluble impurities. 3: the filtrate is covered with a watch glass and left to cool slowly, and crystals form. 4: the crystals are filtered off, rinsed and dried.1Heat and stir to make ahot saturated solution2Filter the hot solutionto remove dirt3Cover and let itcool slowly4Filter off, rinse anddry the crystalswatchglassBlue crystals ofcopper sulphate
Figure 3. Steps in the crystallisation of copper sulphate.
  1. Put 1 g of copper sulphate in 25 mL of water with a drop of dilute sulphuric acid (it stops unwanted reactions, so the crystals are pure).
  2. Warm in a water bath, stirring, and keep adding copper sulphate until no more dissolves: a hot saturated solution.
  3. Filter it while hot to remove insoluble impurities.
  4. Cover the filtrate with a watch glass and let it cool slowly without disturbing it.
  5. Filter off the blue crystals, rinse with cold water and dry them on a watch glass.

Safety first

Copper sulphate is poisonous: work with an adult and do not touch it with bare hands. Only a teacher should handle sulphuric acid.

Slow cooling (or slow evaporation)Fast cooling (or fast evaporation)
CrystalsLarge, shiny, well shapedSmall, less well shaped
WhyParticles have time to fit neatly into the patternParticles have little time to arrange themselves

Salt from seawater (Activity 5.4)

  1. Seawater
  2. Saturated solution
  3. Salt crystals

Seawater is let into shallow salt pans. The Sun and wind evaporate the water until the solution is saturated; further evaporation makes salt crystallise. The salt is raked up and purified.

India’s scientific contributions

Coastal communities in India have made salt for centuries. Panga salt was made by boiling concentrated sea brine; karkatch salt by letting seawater evaporate. The two methods gave crystals of different sizes.

Remember

  • Crystallisation: hot saturated solution → cool slowly → pure crystals.
  • Impurities stay behind in the solution or on the filter paper.
  • Slow cooling gives larger crystals.
Quick checkWhy is crystallisation better than evaporating to dryness for getting pure copper sulphate?Show answer

Evaporating to dryness leaves every dissolved impurity in the solid. In crystallisation, the soluble impurities stay dissolved in the leftover liquid, so the crystals are pure.

6Distillation and fractional distillation

Evaporation gets a dissolved solid back, but the solvent is lost to the air. To recover the liquid, or to separate two liquids that mix, we use distillation.

Miscible liquids

Liquids that mix completely to form a single layer, such as acetone and water.

Distillation

Heating a mixture until the liquid with the lower boiling point turns to vapour, then cooling the vapour so it condenses back to a pure liquid, the distillate.

  1. Liquid
  2. Heat: vapour
  3. Cool: liquid (distillate)
A distillation set-up. A mixture of acetone and water is heated in a distillation flask on a tripod and wire gauze over a burner. A thermometer in the neck reads the temperature of the vapour. The vapour passes into a sloping water condenser, with cold water entering at the lower end and leaving at the upper end. The condensed liquid, acetone, drips into a conical flask.ThermometerWater outCondenserWater inDistillate(acetone)Conical flaskDistillationflaskAcetoneand waterWire gauzeBurner
Figure 4. A distillation set-up for separating acetone from water.
  • Simple distillation works when the boiling points differ by at least about 25 °C.
  • Acetone boils at about 56 °C and water at 100 °C: acetone vaporises first and collects in the conical flask; water stays in the flask.
  • It can also recover a liquid from a solution: distilling salt water gives pure water, and the salt stays behind.
  • The condenser is cooled by water flowing in at the lower end and out at the upper end, so the jacket stays full of cold water.
  • The thermometer bulb sits at the side arm, where it reads the temperature of the vapour.

India’s scientific contributions

In Kannauj, Uttar Pradesh, perfume makers have long used the Deg-Bhapka method of distillation. Flowers, leaves or even baked earth are heated in a copper pot (deg); the fragrant vapour passes through a pipe and condenses in a receiver (bhapka). Mitti ka ittar captures the smell of earth after the first rain.

Fractional distillation

Fractional distillation

Separating liquids whose boiling points differ by less than about 25 °C, using a tall column. Each part that collects is called a fraction.

Fractional distillation of crude oil. Heated crude oil from a furnace enters near the bottom of a tall column. The column is hotter at the bottom and cooler at the top. Fractions leave at different heights: petroleum gas at the top, then petrol, kerosene, diesel and lubricating oil, with bitumen at the bottom.Petroleum gasLPG, cooking gasPetrolcarsKeroseneaircraft fuelDieseltrucks, busesLubricating oilmachinesBitumenroadsFurnaceCrude oilCoolerHotter
Figure 5. Products of the fractional distillation of crude oil in a refinery.
  • Crude petroleum from the Earth’s crust is a mixture of many liquids and gases.
  • In a refinery it is heated and fed into a column that is hot at the bottom and cooler at the top. Each fraction condenses at its own height.
  • Fractions include petroleum gas, petrol, kerosene (aviation fuel), diesel, lubricating oil and bitumen.
  • Petroleum gas is liquefied under high pressure and sold in steel cylinders as LPG.

Remember

  • Distillation = evaporation + condensation.
  • Simple distillation: boiling points differ by about 25 °C or more. Fractional distillation: by less.
  • The liquid with the lower boiling point distils first.
Quick checkLiquid P boils at 65 °C and liquid Q at 115 °C. Can simple distillation separate them? Which collects first?Show answer

Yes. The boiling points differ by 50 °C (more than 25 °C). P, with the lower boiling point, distils first.

7Paper chromatography

Paper chromatography

A method of separating the components of a mixture, such as the dyes in an ink, by letting a solvent carry them up a strip of paper. The components move at different speeds, so they separate.

Paper chromatography. At the start, a spot of black ink sits on a pencil line near the bottom of a paper strip that dips into water in a gas jar; the water level is below the spot. Some time later the water has risen up the paper to the solvent front and the ink has separated into spots of different colours at different heights.At the startSome time laterGas jarPaper stripInk spotPencil lineWaterSolventfrontSeparateddyes
Figure 6. Separating the dyes in black ink by paper chromatography.

Activity 5.5: method

  1. Draw a pencil line 2 cm from the bottom of a strip of chromatography or filter paper. (Ink would run.)
  2. Put a small spot of black sketch-pen ink on the line.
  3. Dip the strip in a little water in a jar so that the water level is below the spot. (Otherwise the ink would dissolve away into the water.)
  4. Watch the water rise. The ink moves up and splits into spots of different colours.
  • Black ink is a mixture of several dyes. The dye that dissolves better and clings less to the paper travels further.
  • It also separates the colours in food colouring (with 2 % m/v salt solution as the solvent) and the pigments in spinach leaves or flower petals.
  • Water does not dissolve every substance. Some pigments need another solvent, such as alcohol or a mixture of solvents.
  • The word comes from Greek chroma, colour, and graphein, to write: it was first used to separate coloured substances.

Remember

  • Pencil line, small spot, solvent below the spot.
  • Components separate because they move up the paper at different speeds.
Quick checkWhy is the starting line drawn in pencil, not ink?Show answer

Pencil (graphite) does not dissolve in the solvent, so the line stays put. An ink line would dissolve and its dyes would mix with those being tested.

8Separating immiscible liquids

Immiscible liquids

Liquids that do not mix and form separate layers, such as oil and water.

A separating funnel held in a clamp on a stand. Yellow mustard oil, the lighter liquid, floats as the upper layer on water, the denser liquid. Opening the stopcock at the bottom lets the water run out into a beaker first.StopperSeparating funnelMustard oil (lighter)Water (denser)StopcockBeaker
Figure 7. Separating mustard oil from water with a separating funnel.

Activity 5.6: using a separating funnel

  1. Pour the mixture (5 mL mustard oil and 20 mL water) into a separating funnel and let it stand.
  2. Two layers form: the lighter (less dense) oil on top, the denser water below.
  3. Open the stopcock slowly to run off the water; close it just before the oil reaches it.
  4. Throw away the small middle portion that may hold both, then run the oil into another container.
  • The method uses two properties: the liquids do not mix, and they have different densities.
  • If two immiscible liquids had the same density, they would not settle into a top and a bottom layer, so they could not be separated this way.

Mixtures that contain a gas

  • Gas particles move freely in all directions, so gases mix evenly: most mixtures of gases are homogeneous, such as hydrogen and oxygen used as rocket fuel.
  • Heterogeneous mixtures with a gas: smoke (solid particles in air), fog (tiny water droplets in air) and dust in air.

Remember

  • Separating funnel: for immiscible liquids of different densities.
  • The denser liquid forms the lower layer and is run off first.
Quick checkA cooking oil pack says 1 litre has a mass of 910 g. Will the oil float on water?Show answer

Yes. 1 litre of water has a mass of about 1000 g, so the oil is less dense than water. It does not mix with water and forms the upper layer.

9Sublimation, and alloys

Sublimation

A solid changing directly into vapour on heating, below its melting point, without becoming a liquid.

Deposition

The vapour changing directly back into a solid on cooling, without becoming a liquid.

Sublimation of camphor. A china dish holding a mixture of camphor and sand is heated gently on a wire gauze. An inverted glass funnel with a cotton plug in its stem covers the dish. Camphor turns to vapour and deposits as a white solid on the cool inner wall of the funnel; the sand stays in the dish.Cotton plugGlass funnelCamphor depositsChina dishCamphor and sandWire gauzeBurner
Figure 8. Separating camphor from sand by sublimation (Activity 5.7).
  • A mixture of crushed camphor and sand is heated gently in a china dish under an inverted funnel plugged with cotton.
  • Camphor sublimes; its vapour deposits as a white solid on the cool inner wall of the funnel. Sand does not sublime and stays in the dish.
  • Other substances that sublime: naphthalene (moth balls), ammonium chloride, iodine, and dry ice (solid carbon dioxide, used to keep ice cream cold).
SublimationEvaporation
Change of stateSolid → vapour (no liquid)Liquid → vapour
Used to separateA solid that sublimes from one that does notA dissolved solid from its solvent

Alloys

Alloy

A homogeneous mixture of two or more metals, or of a metal and a non-metal. It is made by melting the parts together and letting the mixture solidify.

  • Metals do not dissolve in each other at room temperature, but they do when molten.
  • The parts of an alloy cannot be separated by physical methods.
  • Alloys are made to be stronger, harder or more resistant to corrosion than the pure metals.
AlloyMade of (approximately)
BrassCopper 80% and zinc 20%
BronzeCopper 80% and tin 20%
Stainless steelIron with carbon (0.03–0.8%), chromium (16–18%), nickel (10–14%) and molybdenum (2–3%)

Remember

  • Sublimation: solid → vapour directly; deposition: vapour → solid directly.
  • Use sublimation when only one solid sublimes.
  • An alloy is a homogeneous mixture; physical methods cannot separate it.
Quick checkHow would you separate ammonium chloride from common salt?Show answer

By sublimation: heat the mixture under an inverted funnel. Ammonium chloride sublimes and deposits on the funnel; salt stays behind.

10Suspensions, centrifugation and coagulation

Suspension

A heterogeneous mixture in which solid particles do not dissolve but stay spread through the liquid for a while. The particles are large enough to see and settle when left undisturbed.

  • Examples: sand in water, chalk in water, muddy water, sawdust in water, tea leaves in water.
  • Muddy water left to stand: the heavier mud settles (sedimentation), and the clear water can be poured off (decantation) or filtered.
  • Very fine particles pass through cloth and filter paper, so filtered water may still look cloudy. Then we use centrifugation or coagulation.

A. Centrifugation

Centrifugation

Spinning a mixture in tubes at high speed. The heavier particles are thrown outwards and settle at the bottom of each tube; the lighter liquid stays on top.

  • You feel the same outward pull when you hold hands with a partner and spin round together (phugadi in Marathi, kikli in Punjabi).
  • Uses: separating blood into its parts in laboratories, cream from milk in dairies, and many processes in industry.
Centrifugation of blood. Before spinning, a blood sample in a tube looks uniformly red. After spinning in a centrifuge it separates into layers: pale yellow plasma at the top, a thin layer of white blood cells and platelets, and the heavier red blood cells at the bottom.Blood sampleAfter spinningCentrifugePlasmaWhite blood cellsand plateletsRed blood cells
Figure 9. A blood sample before and after centrifugation.

Bridging science and society

The paperfuge is a cheap, hand-powered spinner made of a cardboard disc and string, like a button toy. It spins a blood sample fast enough to separate it without electricity, helping to test for malaria and anaemia in remote places.

Donating blood saves lives. Donated blood is tested, then separated into plasma, platelets and red and white blood cells, which are stored in blood banks. The body replaces donated blood within a few weeks.

B. Coagulation

Coagulation

Adding a substance (a coagulant) that makes fine suspended particles clump together into larger lumps that settle.

Coagulation. Muddy water has very fine particles spread through it. When powdered alum is added, the fine particles clump together into larger lumps. The lumps settle at the bottom, leaving clear water above.Muddy waterAlum added:particles clumpClumps settle;clear water above
Figure 10. Alum (fitkari) makes the fine particles in muddy water clump and settle.
  • Alum is a white crystalline substance used in water purification. After the clumps settle, the water is decanted or filtered.
  • Making paneer: lemon juice or vinegar is the coagulant that clumps the milk proteins.

Remember

  • Suspension: large, visible particles that settle.
  • Centrifugation: fast spinning; heavier particles go to the bottom.
  • Coagulation: a coagulant (alum) makes fine particles clump and settle.
Quick checkIn a centrifuged blood sample, why are the red blood cells at the bottom?Show answer

They are the heaviest part. Spinning pushes heavier particles outwards, which is the bottom of the tube when it swings out.

11Colloids and the Tyndall effect

Colloid

A mixture whose particles are bigger than in a solution but smaller than in a suspension. They are too small to see and stay spread evenly: they do not settle.

Blood is neither a solution nor a true suspension: it is a colloid. So are milk, tomato sauce and ice cream.

Particle sizes compared. In a solution the particles are smaller than 1 nm and cannot be seen. In a colloid they are 1 nm to 1000 nm across. In a suspension they are larger than 1000 nm, can be seen and settle at the bottom.Solutionsmaller than 1 nmColloid1 nm to 1000 nmSuspensionlarger than 1000 nmParticle size increases
Figure 11. Solutions, colloids and suspensions differ mainly in the size of their particles (1 nm is a millionth of a millimetre).

Tyndall effect

The scattering of light by particles, which makes the path of a beam of light visible. It is named after John Tyndall, who studied it.

  • Colloids and suspensions show the Tyndall effect; true solutions do not (see Figure 1).
  • Everyday examples: sunlight streaming through gaps in trees or into a dark, dusty room; floodlight beams in a stadium; headlights in fog.

Parts of a colloid

  • Dispersed phase: the solute-like particles spread through the colloid.
  • Dispersion medium: the substance in which they are spread.

Emulsions

An emulsion is a colloid of two liquids, such as oil and water. Milk and vanishing cream are oil-in-water emulsions; butter, cold cream and body lotions are water-in-oil emulsions. An emulsifying agent keeps an emulsion from separating: proteins do this in milk and butter, and soap does it when you shake a little oil with soapy water.

Solutions, suspensions and colloids compared (Activity 5.9)

PropertySolutionSuspensionColloid
NatureHomogeneousHeterogeneousHeterogeneous (looks homogeneous)
Particle sizeLess than 1 nmMore than 1000 nm1 nm to 1000 nm
Particles visible?NoYes, to the naked eyeNo (seen only with a microscope)
Separated by filtration?NoYesNo
Settles on standing?NoYesNo
Tyndall effectNoYesYes
ExamplesSalt water, sugar water, vinegarMuddy water, chalk in water, sand in waterMilk, blood, fog, ice cream

Remember

  • Particle size: solution < 1 nm; colloid 1–1000 nm; suspension > 1000 nm.
  • Colloids and suspensions scatter light (Tyndall effect); solutions do not.
  • Only suspensions settle and can be filtered.
Quick checkWhy do cities with a lot of smoke and dust look hazy?Show answer

The smoke and dust particles in the air scatter light (the Tyndall effect), so distant objects look blurred and the air looks hazy.

12Choosing a separation method

Each method uses a property in which the parts of a mixture differ: size, density, solubility, boiling point, or how fast they move with a solvent.

MethodProperty usedExample
FiltrationParticle size: insoluble solid particles do not pass through the filterChalk from water
EvaporationThe solvent turns to vapour; the dissolved solid does notSalt from salt water
CrystallisationSolubility changes with temperaturePure copper sulphate from an impure sample
DistillationBoiling points differ (by 25 °C or more)Acetone from water; pure water from salt water
Fractional distillationBoiling points differ (by less than 25 °C)Fractions of crude oil
Paper chromatographyComponents move up the paper at different speedsDyes in ink; pigments in leaves
Separating funnelLiquids do not mix and have different densitiesOil from water
SublimationOne solid sublimes, the other does notCamphor from sand
CentrifugationHeavier particles move outwards when spunParts of blood; cream from milk
CoagulationA coagulant makes fine particles clump and settleClearing muddy water with alum

Separation in nature and society

  • Our kidneys separate wastes from the blood.
  • Sewage treatment uses sedimentation, coagulation and filtration; the cleaned water can be reused for flushing toilets or watering plants.
  • Segregating waste at home: dry waste (plastic, paper, glass, metal) can be recycled; wet waste (food scraps, peels) can be composted.
  • Valuable materials such as lithium can be recovered from old phone and laptop batteries.
  • Some mixtures are hard to separate fully: once lemonade is mixed, getting back each of its ingredients is not simple.

Common mistakes

  • Dividing by the mass of the solvent instead of the mass of the solution in percentage problems.
  • Thinking milk is homogeneous: it is a colloid, a heterogeneous mixture.
  • Thinking an alloy is heterogeneous: it is homogeneous and cannot be separated physically.
  • Putting the ink spot below the solvent level in chromatography.
  • Saying sublimation is the same as evaporation.

Remember

  • Match the method to the property that differs.
  • Several methods may be needed in turn, for example sublimation, then filtration, then evaporation for sand, salt and naphthalene.
Test yourselfTake the 25-question practice quiz on this chapter.