Chapter 2 · Science

Exploring Substances: Acidic, Basic, and Neutral

Acidic, basic and neutral substances, how indicators such as litmus, red rose extract and turmeric tell them apart, and how neutralisation is used in daily life.

Done reading? Try the Indicator detective activity on this chapter.
In this chapter 7 topics
  1. 1Sour, bitter and soapy substances
  2. 2Indicators and litmus
  3. 3Red rose extract and other natural indicators
  4. 4Turmeric and smell as indicators
  5. 5Comparing indicators and secret messages
  6. 6Neutralisation: when acids meet bases
  7. 7Neutralisation in daily life

1Sour, bitter and soapy substances

Our kitchens are full of substances that taste or feel different. Lemon, amla, tamarind (imli) and curd taste sour. Bitter gourd (karela) tastes bitter. Soap feels slippery between your fingers. Scientists use differences like these to sort substances into three groups.

Acidic, basic and neutral

Sour substances, like lemon juice, are acidic. They contain acids. Substances that feel soapy or slippery, like soap solution, are usually basic. They contain bases. Substances that are neither acidic nor basic are neutral.

Many of the substances below are solutions. A solution is a liquid with something mixed evenly into it, like sugar stirred into water. Lime water is a clear solution of lime in water. Lime is the white chuna used in whitewash and paan.

AcidicBasicNeutral
Lemon juiceSoap solutionTap water
Amla juiceBaking soda solutionSugar solution
Tamarind waterLime waterCommon salt solution
VinegarWashing powder solution

Why we cannot just taste them

Taste and touch are not safe tests, and they are not reliable either. Here is why:

  • Some acids and bases in a laboratory are strong. They can burn your tongue and skin.
  • Some substances are poisonous.
  • Taste can fool you. A bitter taste does not prove that something is basic.

So we need a safe test. The best tests show the type of a substance by a change in colour (or sometimes smell). A substance that does this is called an indicator. The next topic explains it.

Safety: never taste or touch an unknown substance to find out what it is. Use acids, bases, hot water and chemicals only when your teacher or another adult is with you. Wash your hands afterwards.

Remember

  • Acidic substances taste sour: lemon, amla, tamarind, vinegar.
  • Basic substances usually feel slippery: soap, baking soda, lime water, washing powder.
  • Neutral substances are neither: pure water, sugar solution, salt solution.
  • Never taste or touch an unknown substance to test it.
Quick checkWhy is it not a good idea to find out whether a liquid is acidic by tasting it?Show answer

The liquid may be harmful. Strong acids and bases can burn the mouth, and some substances are poisonous. Taste can also mislead us. It is safer to use an indicator.

2Indicators and litmus

Acid-base indicator

An acid-base indicator is a substance that shows one colour in acidic solutions and a different colour in basic ones. (A few show a change in smell instead.) It tells us the type of a substance without tasting or touching it.

Think of an indicator like a traffic signal. You do not need to ask the driver anything. You just look at the colour and know what it means.

Litmus

The most common indicator in a school laboratory is litmus. It is a natural dye (colouring) that comes from lichens. Lichens are small living things that grow as patches on rocks and tree bark. Litmus is sold as a liquid, or soaked into strips of paper. It comes in two colours: blue litmus and red litmus.

SolutionBlue litmusRed litmus
Acidicturns redno change (stays red)
Basicno change (stays blue)turns blue
Neutralno changeno change
Blue and red litmus paper strips standing in three beakers. In acidic lemon juice, the wet end of blue litmus turns red and red litmus stays red. In basic soap solution, blue litmus stays blue and the wet end of red litmus turns blue. In neutral sugar solution, neither strip changes colour.Acidiclemon juiceBlueturnsredRedstaysredBasicsoap solutionBluestaysblueRedturnsblueNeutralsugar solutionBluestaysblueRedstaysred
Figure 1. Blue and red litmus strips dipped in an acidic, a basic and a neutral solution.

An easy way to remember: acids turn blue litmus red, and bases turn red litmus blue. A neutral solution changes neither (see Figure 1).

How to test a solution with litmus paper

  1. Pour a little of the solution into a clean cup or test tube.
  2. Dip a clean dropper or glass rod into it.
  3. Touch the wet tip to a strip of blue litmus paper. Then touch it to a strip of red litmus paper.
  4. Note any colour change.
  5. Rinse the dropper before you test the next solution. This stops the solutions from mixing.

Why do we need both colours? Suppose blue litmus stays blue. The solution could be basic or neutral, because neither changes blue litmus. The red strip settles it: if it turns blue, the solution is basic; if not, it is neutral.

Remember

  • An indicator shows by its colour whether a substance is acidic, basic or neutral.
  • Litmus comes from lichens and is used as blue and red litmus.
  • Acids turn blue litmus red; bases turn red litmus blue; neutral solutions change neither.
Quick checkA solution turns red litmus paper blue. Blue litmus paper does not change. What is the nature of the solution? Name one such solution.Show answer

It is basic. Examples: soap solution, baking soda solution or lime water.

3Red rose extract and other natural indicators

Litmus is not the only natural indicator. Many red, purple and blue flowers, fruits and vegetables also change colour with acids and bases. We can make our own indicator from red rose petals.

Making red rose extract

An extract is a liquid that has taken out (extracted) the colour or flavour of something. Tea is an everyday extract: hot water pulls the colour and taste out of tea leaves.

Four pictures showing how to make red rose extract: 1, fallen red rose petals collected on a plate; 2, the petals crushed in a mortar and pestle; 3, the petals soaking in a beaker of hot water, with an adult; 4, the liquid filtered through filter paper in a funnel, giving a red liquid, the red rose extract.1Collect fallenrose petals2Wash them andcrush them3Soak in hot water(with an adult)4Cool, then filter:red rose extract
Figure 2. Making red rose extract. Use petals that have already fallen; do not pluck flowers.
  1. Collect red rose petals that have already fallen.
  2. Wash them and crush them.
  3. Soak them in hot water for a while, with an adult’s help. The colour moves into the water.
  4. Let it cool. Then filter it: pour it through filter paper or a clean cloth. This removes the bits of petal, just as a tea strainer removes tea leaves.

The coloured liquid that comes through is the red rose extract. You can also soak strips of filter paper or blotting paper in it and let them dry. These are red rose paper strips.

SolutionColour of red rose extract
Acidic (lemon juice, vinegar)turns red
Basic (soap, baking soda solution)turns green
Neutral (sugar, salt solution)no change

Why is red rose extract so useful? It changes colour in acids and in bases, and stays the same in neutral solutions. So this one indicator can tell all three kinds of solution apart.

Other natural indicators

You can also make indicators from beetroot, purple (red) cabbage, jamun and red hibiscus (China rose, gudhal) flowers. Make them the same way: crush, soak in hot water, cool and filter. Try them out with your teacher, and record the colours you see in a table.

Hot water can scald (burn your skin). Do the soaking step only with an adult.

Remember

  • Red rose extract is made by crushing petals, soaking them in hot water and filtering.
  • Red rose extract: red in acids, green in bases, no change in neutral solutions.
  • Beetroot, purple cabbage, jamun and hibiscus can also be used as natural indicators.
Quick checkA few drops of red rose extract are added to a liquid, and it turns green. Is the liquid acidic, basic or neutral?Show answer

It is basic. Red rose extract turns green in basic solutions.

4Turmeric and smell as indicators

Turmeric as an indicator

Turmeric (haldi) is yellow. In a basic solution it turns red. In acidic and neutral solutions it stays yellow.

You may have seen this at home. A yellow haldi stain on a cloth turns reddish when the cloth is washed with soap. This happens because soap is basic.

Turmeric paper is easy to make:

  1. Mix a little turmeric powder with water to make a paste.
  2. Spread it on blotting paper or filter paper.
  3. Let it dry, then cut it into strips.
SolutionTurmeric
Acidicstays yellow
Basicturns red
Neutralstays yellow

What turmeric cannot do

Turmeric picks out bases. But it cannot tell an acid from a neutral substance, because both leave it yellow. To tell them apart, you need a second indicator, such as blue litmus or red rose extract.

There is a clever trick, though.

  1. Dip a turmeric strip in a base, such as soap solution. It turns red.
  2. Dip the red part into the liquid you want to test.
  3. If the red changes back to yellow, the liquid is acidic. Why? The acid has cancelled the base on the strip.
  4. If it stays red, the liquid is neutral. Nothing cancelled the base.
The turmeric trick. A yellow turmeric paper strip is dipped in soap solution, and its end turns red because soap is a base. The red end is then dipped in the liquid to be tested. If it turns back to yellow, the liquid is acidic. If it stays red, the liquid is neutral.Turmericstripdip in soapRed end(base on it)dip in test liquidBack to yellowAcidicorStays redNeutral
Figure 3. The turmeric trick: telling an acid from a neutral liquid.

Indicators you can smell

Some indicators change their smell, not their colour. These are called olfactory indicators. (Olfactory means “to do with smell”.)

Chopped onion is one. In an acidic solution, its smell stays. In a basic solution, you can no longer smell the onion. Olfactory indicators are useful for people who cannot see.

Remember

  • Turmeric turns red in basic solutions and stays yellow in acidic and neutral ones.
  • Turmeric alone cannot tell an acid from a neutral substance.
  • Olfactory indicators, such as onion, change smell instead of colour.
Quick checkA yellow turmeric stain on a shirt turns red when the shirt is washed with soap. Why?Show answer

Soap solution is basic, and turmeric turns red in basic solutions.

5Comparing indicators and secret messages

Each indicator has its own colours. The chart below puts them side by side. Each colour is also written in words.

Colour chart of four indicators. Blue litmus turns red in acidic solutions and stays blue in neutral and basic ones. Red litmus stays red in acidic and neutral solutions and turns blue in basic ones. Red rose extract turns red in acidic solutions, does not change in neutral ones and turns green in basic ones. Turmeric stays yellow in acidic and neutral solutions and turns red in basic ones.AcidicNeutralBasicBlue litmusturns redstays bluestays blueRed litmusstays redstays redturns blueRed rose extractturns redno changeturns greenTurmericstays yellowstays yellowturns red
Figure 4. How four indicators behave in acidic, neutral and basic solutions.

Which indicator should I use?

  • To tell all three kinds apart in one test: use red rose extract, or use both red and blue litmus.
  • To find out only whether something is basic: use turmeric.
  • For a person who cannot see: use an olfactory indicator such as onion.

Secret messages

Indicators can make invisible writing appear. Here is how:

  1. Dip a cotton bud in a colourless acid or base, such as lemon juice or baking soda solution.
  2. Write a message with it on white paper. Let it dry. The writing is now invisible.
  3. Spray or brush an indicator over the paper.
  4. The writing appears in a different colour from the rest of the sheet. This happens because the indicator changes colour only where the acid or base is.
Write withSpray withColour of the writing
Soap solution or baking soda solution (basic)Turmeric solutionred, on a yellow sheet
Lemon juice or vinegar (acidic)Blue litmus solutionred, on a blue sheet
Baking soda solution (basic)Red rose extractgreen

Remember

  • Acids: blue litmus red; red rose extract red; turmeric stays yellow.
  • Bases: red litmus blue; red rose extract green; turmeric red.
  • Neutral: no change in any of these indicators.
Quick checkYou have only turmeric paper. Can you be sure that a liquid which leaves it yellow is acidic?Show answer

No. Turmeric stays yellow in both acidic and neutral liquids. You need another indicator, such as blue litmus, to decide.

Try it yourselfSort substances into acidic, basic and neutral, predict what each indicator will do, and pick the right fix for everyday problems in the Indicator detective game.

6Neutralisation: when acids meet bases

What happens when you mix an acidic substance with a basic one? Let us find out with an activity your teacher can show you.

Activity: cancelling an acid

  1. Take a little lemon juice in a test tube. Add some water to make it weaker (to dilute it).
  2. Add a few drops of blue litmus solution. It turns red, so the liquid is acidic.
  3. Now add lime water (a base) one drop at a time. Shake gently after each drop.
  4. After enough drops, the colour changes back to blue. Why? The base has used up all the acid, and now there is a little base left over.
  5. Add one drop of lemon juice again. The colour turns red once more, because now there is a little acid left over.
The neutralisation activity, with three test tubes in a wooden rack. Tube 1: diluted lemon juice with blue litmus solution is red. Tube 2: lime water is added drop by drop from a dropper. Tube 3: when enough base has been added, the colour changes back to blue.lime water(a base)Lemon juice +blue litmus: redAdd lime waterdrop by dropColour changesback to blue
Figure 5. Adding a base to an acid, with litmus to show the change.

Neutralisation

When an acid and a base react, they cancel each other’s effect. This reaction is called neutralisation. It makes a salt and water, and gives out heat.

Neutralisation: an acid, such as lemon juice, plus a base, such as lime water, gives a salt (a new substance) plus water, and heat is given out.Acidlemon juice+Baselime waterheatgiven outSaltnew substance+Water
Figure 6. Acid + base → salt + water, with heat given out.

Here, the word salt means any new substance formed when an acid and a base react. Common salt, which we put in food, is just one of many salts.

Because heat is given out, the mixture becomes a little warmer. With a larger amount of acid and base, you can feel this by touching the outside of the test tube.

The amounts matter. If you add too much base, the mixture becomes basic. If you add too much acid, it becomes acidic again. The indicator shows you which one is left over.

Safety: never taste or touch an unknown substance to find out what it is. Use acids, bases, hot water and chemicals only when your teacher or another adult is with you. Wash your hands afterwards.

Remember

  • Acid + base → salt + water, and heat is given out.
  • This reaction is called neutralisation.
  • An indicator shows when the acid has been neutralised.
Quick checkLime water is added drop by drop to vinegar that has been coloured red by blue litmus. What will you see, and why?Show answer

The red colour will change to blue. The lime water (a base) neutralises the vinegar (an acid). Once there is a little extra base, litmus turns blue.

7Neutralisation in daily life

Neutralisation does not happen only in a laboratory. We use it to solve many everyday problems. In each one, a base cancels an unwanted acid (see Figure 7).

Neutralisation in daily life, in four pictures. An ant bite puts formic acid in the skin; a moist paste of baking soda eases the pain. Acidic soil gives poor crops; lime (chuna) is added so plants grow well. Too much acid in the stomach is eased by an antacid, a mild base. Acidic factory waste has a base added before it is let out into a river, so it is safer for fish.BAKINGSODAAnt biteformic acid in the skin+ baking soda paste: less painLIMEAcidic soilpoor crops+ lime (chuna): plants grow wellToo much stomach acidacidity, a burning feeling+ antacid, a mild base: reliefLIMEAcidic factory wasteharms fish+ a base first: safer for fish
Figure 7. Everyday problems caused by acids, and the bases that fix them.

Ant bite

When an ant bites, it puts an acid called formic acid into your skin. This causes pain and a burning feeling. Baking soda is basic. So rubbing a paste of moist baking soda on the bite neutralises the acid and eases the pain.

Treating soil

Plants grow well only when the soil is not too acidic and not too basic. A farmer or gardener can test the soil like this:

  1. Mix some soil with water and stir.
  2. Let the soil settle to the bottom.
  3. Filter the water to get a clear liquid.
  4. Test the clear liquid with an indicator, such as litmus.

Then the soil can be treated. Organic matter means material from things that were once alive, such as cow-dung manure, compost and rotting leaves.

If the soil isIt can be treated withBecause
Too acidicLime (quicklime or slaked lime)Lime is a base; it neutralises the acid
Too basicOrganic matter: manure, compost or rotting leavesIt releases acids that neutralise the base
Neutral, but plants still look poorManure or fertiliserThe soil may be short of nutrients (the “food” plants take from soil)

Soil can even change the colour of flowers. Hydrangea, a garden plant, gives blue flowers in acidic soil and pink or red flowers in basic soil.

Factory wastes

The wastes of many factories contain acids. If these flow into a river or lake, they make the water acidic. This can kill fish and other water life. So factories should first add a base to neutralise the wastes. Only then should the wastes be let out.

Too much acid in the stomach

Your stomach makes an acid that helps break down (digest) food. Sometimes it makes too much. This causes a burning feeling called acidity, or indigestion. Medicines called antacids (“anti” means against) contain a mild base. It neutralises the extra acid. Take them only when a doctor or an adult advises.

Remember

  • Ant bite (formic acid): rub moist baking soda (a base).
  • Acidic soil: add lime. Basic soil: add organic matter.
  • Acidic factory wastes are neutralised with a base before release.
  • Antacids neutralise extra stomach acid.
Quick checkA farmer finds that a solution made from her field’s soil turns blue litmus red. What should she add to the soil?Show answer

The soil is acidic, so she should add lime, a base, to neutralise it.

Test yourselfTake the 16-question practice quiz on this chapter.