Chapter 1 · Nature of science

Exploration: Entering the World of Secondary Science

How science works at the secondary stage: models and why they leave out details, the precise language of science with its symbols and standard units, mathematics as a language, laws, theories and principles, predictions and how they are tested, the limits of theories, estimation, the branches of science and how they connect, and science as a human activity.

Complete answers to every question in this chapter of the NCERT textbook: the three worked examples, Activity 1.1, the three Pause and Ponder questions and the estimation task in the ‘Ready to Go Beyond’ box. This chapter has no exercises at the end. Each question is given exactly as it appears in the book.

Example 1.1 and Activity 1.1

Making simple models

  1. Q1
    Example 1.1: A cricket shot. Think of a cricket ball being hit for a six. You want to make a simple model. What details would you include? What would you ignore?

    Answer

    First fix the question the model must answer: will the ball cross the boundary without touching the ground? Then sort the details by how much they affect this answer.

    DetailEffect on the answerIn a simple model
    Speed with which the ball is hitLargeInclude
    Direction (angle) in which it is hitLargeInclude
    Mass of the ballLargeInclude
    Distance to the boundaryLargeInclude
    Air resistanceSmallIgnore
    Spin of the ballSmallIgnore
    Stitching of the seamSmallIgnore
    Brand of the bat, colour of the ball, grass on the fieldNoneIgnore

    Ignoring the small effects keeps the model simple. For greater accuracy, a more complex model can add them back, one by one.

  2. Q2
    Activity 1.1: Let us model
    Suppose you ride a bicycle from your school to your home. You want to model the time it takes to go home from school. What details would you keep? What details could you ignore? Suggest why ignoring some details may actually be useful.

    Answer

    Details to keep (they change the time a lot):

    • the distance from school to home along the route;
    • your average cycling speed;
    • the stops on the way (traffic signals, crossings) and how long you wait at each;
    • steep slopes and heavy traffic, which slow you down.

    Details to ignore (little or no effect): the colour or brand of the bicycle, the colour of your bag, small bumps on the road, a light breeze, the exact path round each corner.

    A simple model: time = distanceaverage speed + waiting time at stops. For example, for a 3 km ride at an average speed of 5 m/s with two stops of about 1 minute each:

    Ride=3000 m5 m/s=600 s=10 minutesTotal=10 min + 2 × 1 min≈about 12 minutes

    Why ignoring details is useful:

    • The model becomes simple and quick to use, yet still gives a good enough answer.
    • It shows clearly which factors really matter (distance, speed, stops).
    • Measuring every tiny detail would take a lot of effort and would hardly change the answer.
    • If the answer is not accurate enough, details can be added back later.

Pause and Ponder 1 and Example 1.2

Predictions

  1. Q1
    Pause and Ponder 1. Think of a prediction you or your family made recently (for example, the outcome of a cricket match). Was it based on evidence and reasoning, or mainly on guesswork? How can scientific thinking improve such predictions?

    Answer

    A sample answer (your own example may differ):

    Before a cricket match, my uncle predicted that our team would win “because we always win when I watch at home”. This was mainly guesswork: there is no way that where he watches can affect the game.

    Scientific thinking would improve the prediction by:

    • using evidence: recent results of both teams, their record against each other, the form of key players;
    • using measurable conditions: the pitch report and the weather forecast (rain, dew);
    • giving reasons for the prediction and saying how likely it is, not that it is certain;
    • checking the prediction against the result, and if it was wrong, re-examining the reasons and assumptions.
  2. Q2
    Example 1.2: How do we check predictions? Varsha told her friend Meghna, “It will rain this afternoon because the clouds look dark”. Think of some questions Meghna could ask Varsha to make this prediction scientifically testable.

    Answer

    Good questions ask for measurable data and past patterns. A plain yes or no answer is not very useful. Meghna could ask:

    1. What is the humidity today? What was it the last few times it rained?
    2. Is the air pressure falling, as it often does before rain?
    3. What are the wind speed and direction? Is the wind bringing moist air from the sea?
    4. Is the temperature dropping, as it did before recent rain?
    5. What did the sky look like the last time it rained, and how often have dark clouds been followed by rain?

    Answers to such questions can be measured and compared with the past, so the prediction can be tested. They go beyond the simple remark that “the clouds look dark”.

Ready to Go Beyond, Example 1.3 and Pause and Ponder 2

Estimation

  1. Q1
    Ready to Go Beyond: How much rice would feed a family of four for a month?
    To make a rough estimate, assume that all their calorie needs come from rice alone (Fig. 1.3). An average adult needs about 2000 – 2500 kilocalories (kcal) per day. Find out how many calories 100 g of uncooked rice provides when cooked and use this to estimate the daily requirement for the family.

    Answer

    100 g of uncooked rice gives about 350 kcal of energy (cooking adds water, not energy). Take about 2250 kcal a day for each person, the middle of the range.

    Energy=4 × 2250 kcal=9000 kcal a dayRice a day=9000 kcal350 kcal × 100 g≈about 2600 g≈about 2.6 kgPer month=2.6 kg × 30≈about 80 kg

    So the family needs roughly 2.5 kg of rice a day, or about 80 kg a month.

    Does it make sense? Yes: it is far more than 100 g (clearly too little) and far less than a few tonnes (clearly too much). In reality the family would need less, because children need less energy and people eat other foods too.

    A scale from 10 grams to 10 tonnes, each step ten times the last. 100 grams of rice for a month is far too little; a few tonnes is far too much; the estimate of about 80 kilograms lies sensibly between them.10 g100 g1 kg10 kg100 kg1 t10 tFar toolittleOur estimate:about 80 kgFar toomuchMass of uncooked rice for a month (each step is ×10)
    Checking that the estimate is sensible.
  2. Q2
    Example 1.3: Estimate how many litres of air you breathe in one day. Start by estimating how many breaths you take per minute, and the volume of one breath. Your aim is not to find an exact answer, but a reasonable estimate.

    Answer

    Breaths in a day. At rest we take about 12 to 15 breaths a minute, and a day has 60 × 24 = 1440 minutes. 12 × 1440 is about 17 000 and 15 × 1440 is about 22 000, so we take roughly 20 000 breaths a day.

    Volume of one breath. It takes about 4 to 5 breaths to blow up a party balloon of about 2 litres, so one breath is about 0.5 litre.

    Air a day=20 000 × 0.5 litre≈about 10 000 litres

    Check by another route. A balloon can be blown up in about 20 s, so about 3 balloons a minute:

    Air=3 balloonsminute × 2 litresballoon×1440 minutesday=8640 litres

    The two estimates (about 10 000 litres and 8640 litres) are close, so the answer is reasonable: we breathe about 10 000 litres of air a day. (Blowing balloons non-stop would be tiring, so the second method is only a rough check.)

  3. Q3
    Pause and Ponder 2. Describe one situation where an approximate answer is good enough, and one where you would need a very exact value.

    Answer

    Approximate answer is good enough: deciding how much rice to buy for the family for a month. Buying 75 kg or 85 kg makes little difference; we only need a sensible amount.

    Very exact value needed: the dose of a medicine for a child. Too little will not work and too much can be harmful, so the dose must be measured exactly.

    Other examples: approximate for the time to walk to school or the number of chairs for a function; exact for the fuel loaded into an aircraft or the size of a machine part that must fit.

Pause and Ponder 3

Branches of science

  1. Q1
    Pause and Ponder 3. Choose a real‑life object (maybe a pressure cooker or a mobile phone) or a problem (maybe a traffic jam near your school). Make a sketch listing what kind of ideas from physics, chemistry, biology, earth science, or mathematics are involved. Show how at least two branches of science connect with your example.

    Answer

    Object chosen: a pressure cooker.

    Ideas behind a pressure cooker. Physics: trapped steam raises the pressure, so water boils near 120 °C. Chemistry: starch and proteins in food change faster when hotter. Biology: high heat kills most germs, and soft food is easier to digest. Earth science: there is less air pressure in the hills, so water boils below 100 °C there. Mathematics: cooking time, pressure and temperature can be measured and compared.Physicstrapped steamraises pressure:water boilsnear 120 °CChemistrystarch andproteins in foodchange fasterwhen hotterBiologyhigh heat killsmost germs; softfood is easierto digestEarth scienceless air pressurein the hills, sowater boilsbelow 100 °CMathematicstime, pressure and temperature canbe measured and comparedPressurecooker
    Ideas from different branches of science in a pressure cooker.

    How the branches connect:

    • Physics and chemistry: the lid traps steam, so the pressure inside rises and water boils at a higher temperature (about 120 °C instead of 100 °C). At this higher temperature the chemical changes of cooking (starch softening, proteins changing) happen much faster, so food cooks in less time.
    • Earth science and physics: high in the hills the air pressure is lower, so water boils below 100 °C and food cooks slowly in an open pot. A pressure cooker raises the pressure again, which is why it is so useful in hilly areas.
    • Biology: the high temperature kills most germs, and softer, well-cooked food is easier to digest.