Chapter 11 · Science

Keeping Time with the Skies

The phases of the Moon and why they happen, where and when to see the Moon, how the day, month and year come from the sky, lunar, solar and luni-solar calendars, festivals linked to the Moon and Sun, and artificial satellites.

Answers to all 12 questions under “Keep the curiosity alive” at the end of the chapter. Each question is given exactly as it appears in the book. Figures the questions need are redrawn. The “Discover, design, and debate” projects and the boxes asking you to prepare your own questions are for you to do, so they are not answered here.

Keep the curiosity alive

Questions 1 to 12

  1. Q1
    State whether the following statements are True or False.(i) We can only see that part of the Moon which reflects sunlight towards us.(ii) The shadow of Earth blocks sunlight from reaching the Moon causing phases.(iii) Calendars are based on various astronomical cycles which repeat in a predictable manner.(iv) The Moon can only be seen at night.

    Answer

    • (i) True. The Moon has no light of its own. We see only the sunlit part that faces the Earth.
    • (ii) False. Phases happen because we see different amounts of the Moon’s lit half as it goes round the Earth. Earth’s shadow on the Moon causes a lunar eclipse, not phases.
    • (iii) True. The day, month and year come from the Earth’s spin, the Moon’s cycle of phases and the cycle of seasons. All repeat regularly.
    • (iv) False. The Moon is often seen in the daytime, for example a waning Moon in the morning or a waxing Moon in the afternoon.
  2. Q2
    Amol was born on 6th of May on a full Moon day. Does his birthday fall on the full Moon day every year? Explain your answer.

    Answer

    No.

    • Full Moons come about every 29½ days. Twelve such cycles take 12 × 29½ = 354 days.
    • The Gregorian year has 365 days, which is 11 days more.
    • So one year after his birth, the full Moon falls about 11 days before 6 May (around 25 April). The next one is about 24 May.
    • 6 May is not a full Moon day that year. The full Moon dates keep shifting from year to year.
    • His birthday falls on a full Moon only now and then. It happens again after about 19 years, when the two cycles nearly match.
  3. Q3
    Name two things that are incorrect in Fig. 11.10.
    Fig. 11 redrawn: a crescent Moon in front of two clouds, with stars drawn on the dark part of the Moon.
    Fig. 11.10, redrawn.

    Answer

    1. Stars are shown on the dark part of the Moon. The dark part is still the solid Moon. It blocks the light of stars behind it, so no star can be seen there.
    2. The Moon is shown in front of the clouds. Clouds are only a few kilometres above us, but the Moon is about 384 000 km away. So clouds always pass in front of the Moon and hide it.
    Corrected picture: the clouds are in front of the Moon, and no stars show through the dark part of the Moon.
    Corrected: clouds in front of the Moon, and no stars on its dark part.
  4. Q4
    Look at the pictures of the Moon in Fig. 11.11, and answer the following questions.
    Fig. 11 redrawn: six pictures of the Moon. A: mostly lit, with a thin dark edge at the upper left. B: completely dark. C: lower-right half lit, with a straight edge. D: thin lit crescent at the lower right. E: fully lit. F: lit except for a dark lens-shaped patch at the upper left whose curved edge runs from the left side to the top.ABCDEF
    Fig. 11.11, redrawn.
    (i) Write the correct panel number corresponding to the phases of the Moon shown in the pictures above.
    Picture label (e.g. A, B, C, etc.)Phase of Moon
    Three days after New Moon
    Full Moon
    Three days after Full Moon
    A week after Full Moon
    Day of New Moon
    (ii) List the picture labels of the phases of the Moon that are never seen from Earth. Hint: You can use your observations from Activity 11.1 or Fig. 11.2 as reference.

    Answer

    (i)

    Picture labelPhase of Moon
    DThree days after New Moon (thin crescent)
    EFull Moon (whole disc bright)
    AThree days after Full Moon (gibbous: a little less than full)
    CA week after Full Moon (half Moon)
    BDay of New Moon (not seen)

    (ii) F. The line between the bright and dark parts of the Moon always runs from one end of a diameter to the other end. (The two tips of a crescent always lie on a diameter.) In F, the dark patch starts at the left edge and ends at the top, only a quarter of the way round. The Moon never looks like this.

    The pictures are matched by how much of the disc is bright. Which way the bright side tilts depends on where and when you watch.

  5. Q5
    Malini saw the Moon overhead in the sky at sunset.(i) Draw the phase of the Moon that Malini saw.(ii) Is the Moon in the waxing or the waning phase?

    Answer

    (i) At sunset the Sun is on the western horizon. A Moon that is overhead is a quarter of the way round the sky from the Sun. So it is a half Moon, with its western half (the side towards the Sun) bright.

    At sunset the Sun is on the western horizon and the Moon is high overhead. Malini sees a half Moon (first quarter) with its western half, the side facing the setting Sun, lit.half Moon overhead,lit on the Sun’s sideSun settingEastSouthWest
    A half Moon overhead at sunset, bright on the side facing the setting Sun.

    (ii) Waxing. A half Moon overhead at sunrise is waning. One overhead at sunset is the first quarter, and it keeps growing towards full Moon over the next week.

  6. Q6
    Ravi said, “I saw a crescent Moon, and it was rising in the East, when the Sun was setting.” Kaushalya said, “Once I saw the gibbous Moon during the afternoon in the East.” Who out of the two is telling the truth?

    Answer

    Kaushalya is telling the truth.

    • Ravi: a Moon rising in the east just as the Sun sets in the west is opposite the Sun. That is a full Moon, not a crescent. A crescent is always close to the Sun in the sky. At sunset it is low in the west.
    • Kaushalya: a waxing gibbous Moon, a few days before full Moon, rises in the afternoon. So it can be seen in the east in the afternoon.
  7. Q7
    Scientific studies show that the Moon is getting farther away from the Earth and slower in its revolution. Will luni-solar calendars need an intercalary month more often or less often?

    Answer

    Less often.

    • If the Moon goes round more slowly, one cycle of phases takes longer. So each lunar month gets longer.
    • Then 12 lunar months add up to more than 354 days, closer to the 365-day solar year.
    • The gap between the lunar year and the solar year becomes smaller than 11 days.
    • It takes longer for the gap to add up to a whole month. So the extra month is needed less often.
  8. Q8
    A total of 37 full Moons happen during 3 years in a solar calendar. Show that at least two of the 37 full moons must happen during the same month of the solar calendar.

    Answer

    Months in 3 years=3 × 12=36 months
    • There are 37 full Moons but only 36 months.
    • If each month had at most one full Moon, the 36 months could hold at most 36 full Moons.
    • That leaves at least one full Moon over. It must fall in a month that already has a full Moon.
    • So at least one month has two full Moons. This is possible because full Moons are 29½ days apart, and most months are 30 or 31 days long.
  9. Q9
    On a particular night, Vaishali saw the Moon in the sky from sunset to sunrise. What phase of the Moon would she have noticed?

    Answer

    Full Moon. To be in the sky all night, the Moon must rise at sunset and set at sunrise. It must be opposite the Sun. That is the position of the full Moon, when we see the whole of its lit half.

  10. Q10
    If we stopped having leap years, in approximately how many years would the Indian Independence day happen in winter?

    Answer

    About 700 years.

    • The Earth takes about 365¼ days to go round the Sun. Without leap years, the calendar has only 365 days.
    • So each year the calendar slips about 14 day against the seasons. 15 August would come a little earlier in the season each year: in the season of late July, then June, and so on.
    • Winter in India is from December to February. Going back from mid-August to the end of winter (February) is about 6 months.
    Shift each year=14 dayShift needed=about 6 months≈about 180 daysYears needed=180 days14 day per year=180 × 4=720 years

    So Independence Day would start to fall in winter after roughly 700 years.

  11. Q11
    What is the purpose of launching artificial satellites?

    Answer

    Artificial satellites are launched to do jobs that are best done from space:

    • Communication: carrying phone, TV and internet signals over long distances.
    • Navigation: helping phones, ships and aircraft find their exact position.
    • Weather monitoring: watching clouds and storms for forecasts and cyclone warnings.
    • Disaster management and mapping: pictures of the land for maps, city planning, and handling floods and other disasters (for example, ISRO’s Cartosat satellites).
    • Scientific research: studying stars, the Sun and other bodies (for example, AstroSat).
  12. Q12
    On which periodic phenomenon are the following measures of time based: (i) day (ii) month (iii) year?

    Answer

    • (i) Day: the rotation of the Earth on its axis. The Sun returns to its highest point in the sky about every 24 hours.
    • (ii) Month: the revolution of the Moon around the Earth. Its cycle of phases repeats about every 29½ days.
    • (iii) Year: the revolution of the Earth around the Sun. The cycle of seasons repeats about every 365¼ days.