Exploring the Investigative World of Science
How to investigate like a scientist: ask a focused question, change one thing at a time, measure carefully, keep notes, and see where the Class 8 journey leads.
This chapter has no end-of-chapter exercises. On its first page it has three “Probe and ponder” questions, which are not meant for any exam. They are invitations to be curious, and they are answered here, each given exactly as it appears in the book. The page also asks, “Is there such a question that makes you curious about the world? Write it here!” That is an invitation to write your own question, not a question to answer, so it is not answered here.
Probe and ponder
Probe and ponder
- Q1Probe and ponder 1Why is one side of a puri thinner than the other?
Answer
Short answer. Nobody knows for certain. The book itself says that scientists do not yet fully understand how a puri puffs. Here are ideas that are often suggested. Each one can be tested.
- Steam. The water in the dough turns to steam in the hot oil. Steam takes up far more space than water, so it pushes the dough out like a balloon. When it is trapped inside, it separates the top and bottom layers.
- Uneven rolling. If the dough was thinner on one side, that side stretches more and becomes the thin side.
- One side meets the oil first. The side touching the oil cooks and firms up first. The other side stays soft and stretches more as the steam pushes.
How we could find out. By an investigation. Change one thing at a time and keep the rest the same.
Idea to test We change We observe or measure Uneven rolling matters How evenly it is rolled Which side is thinner; how thin (mm) The side that meets the oil first matters Which side goes in first Which side is thinner Thickness matters Dough thickness Puffing; time to puff (s); thin side Everything else (flour, size, oil temperature, how the dough is dropped in) stays the same, and each test is repeated. Many things happen together in the oil: heating, steam, and the stretching of dough. That is why the question is hard, and why it is still open.
- Q2Probe and ponder 2Are there more grains of sand on all the beaches and deserts of the world, or more stars in our galaxy?
Answer
Answer. There are more grains of sand. These are estimates, not exact counts, but the gap is very large.
Quantity Rough estimate Grains of sand on all beaches and deserts of Earth about 7.5 × 1018 (7.5 billion billion) Stars in our galaxy, the Milky Way about 100 to 400 billion (1 to 4 × 1011) To compare, divide the sand by the stars. Use the largest star estimate, which gives the smallest gap.
Sand per star=7.5 × 10184 × 1011≈1.9 × 107≈about 19 millionSo even then, there are about 19 million grains of sand for every star in the Milky Way. With the smaller star estimate, the gap is nearly four times bigger.
How are such numbers found? Nobody counts. For sand, scientists estimate the total volume of sand and divide it by the volume of one typical grain. For stars, they estimate the total mass of the galaxy and divide it by the typical mass of a star. Both numbers are rough, and they may change as methods improve.
A twist. Our galaxy is only one of billions. The whole observable universe may have around 1022 to 1024 stars (again, a rough estimate). That is far more than the grains of sand on Earth.
- Q3Probe and ponder 3Right from Grade 6, we’ve observed the incredible diversity of plants and animals around us. From the different shapes of leaves to the many kinds of insects — why has nature created such a vast variety?
Answer
Answer. Scientists explain variety by the idea that living things vary, and that the surroundings differ from place to place. Nobody planned each kind. Here is the reasoning in steps.
- Habitats differ. A habitat is the place where a living thing lives. A desert, a pond, a forest floor and a mountain top have different heat, water, light and food.
- Living things vary. Even young ones of the same parents are not exactly alike.
- Some features help survival. The living things whose features suit their habitat are more likely to survive and have young. They pass the helpful features on.
- Over a very long time, many kinds of living things build up, each suited to its own way of life. A feature that helps a living thing survive in its habitat is called an adaptation.
Example Feature How it helps Cactus leaves are spines Few, thin spines instead of broad leaves Less water is lost in a dry desert Water lily leaves are broad and float Flat leaves resting on the water They catch sunlight at the water surface Insects: butterflies, bees, beetles, ants Different mouths, wings and body shapes Each can use a different food in a different place Why is variety useful? A varied community of life is more likely to survive changes, such as a drought or a new disease, because some kinds will cope. Insects alone have over a million known kinds. That is more than half of all the animal kinds known.
You can investigate this yourself. Collect fallen leaves from different places, sort them by shape and size, and ask what each shape might do for the plant.