Chapter 9 · Science

Methods of Separation in Everyday Life

What mixtures are, why we separate them, and the everyday methods we use: handpicking, threshing, winnowing, sieving, evaporation, sedimentation, decantation, filtration, churning and magnets.

Done reading? Try the Separation challenge activity on this chapter.
In this chapter 8 topics
  1. 1Mixtures and why we separate them
  2. 2Handpicking and threshing
  3. 3Winnowing and sieving
  4. 4Evaporation
  5. 5Sedimentation and decantation
  6. 6Filtration
  7. 7Churning and magnetic separation
  8. 8Choosing the right method

1Mixtures and why we separate them

Look at your lunch plate, a handful of soil, or a glass of lemonade. Each one is made of more than one substance mixed together. A substance is one kind of material, such as salt, sugar, water or sand. Very few things around us are just one pure substance.

Mixture

A mixture is made of two or more substances mixed together. Each substance in it is called a component. Each component keeps its own properties.

Properties are what a substance is like. Think of its size, colour and weight. Does it dissolve in water (mix in so fully that you cannot see it)? Does a magnet pull it? Mixing does not change any of these.

A mixture: a steel plate of dal with a few small stones and some husk in it. An arrow points to its three components, each with its own properties. Dal grains: heavier than husk. Small stones: few, grey and hard. Husk: very light, like paper.Mixturedal with stones and huskDal grainsheavier than huskSmall stonesfew, grey and hardHusklight and paperyIts components
Figure 1. A mixture and its components. Each component keeps its own size, colour and weight.

Look at Figure 1. The stones look different from the dal. The husk is much lighter than the grains. We can use these differences to pull the components apart. Pulling the components of a mixture apart is called separation.

Why do we separate mixtures?

There are two main reasons.

ReasonExamples
To remove something that is not useful or is harmfulPicking stones out of dal; straining tea leaves out of tea; cleaning muddy water
To get two different useful partsGetting butter and buttermilk from curd; getting cream from milk

This chapter covers the methods people use every day in homes, farms, kitchens, shops and factories. For each method, ask yourself: which difference between the components does it use?

Remember

  • A mixture has two or more components; each keeps its own properties.
  • We separate mixtures to remove an unwanted part, or to get two useful parts.
  • Every separation method uses some difference between the components.
Quick checkGive one example of separation done to remove an unwanted part, and one done to get two useful parts.Show answer

Removing an unwanted part: picking small stones out of rice. Getting two useful parts: churning curd to get butter and buttermilk.

2Handpicking and threshing

Handpicking

Before rice or dal is cooked, it is spread on a plate. Then small stones, husk, broken grains or insects are picked out by hand. You do the same thing when you take whole spices, such as black pepper or cloves, out of your pulao.

Handpicking

Handpicking means removing the unwanted pieces of a mixture with our hands. It works when the pieces look different in size, colour or shape.

Handpicking is a good method when:

  • there are only a few pieces to remove, so it does not take too long;
  • the pieces are big enough to see and hold;
  • they look clearly different from the rest.

Handpicking would be no use for separating fine sand from salt. It would also take far too long to clean a whole truckload of grain.

Threshing

When wheat or rice is cut from the field, the grains are still stuck to the stalks. The grains sit in the ears, the tops of the stalks. To get them off, the stalks are beaten.

Threshing

Threshing is separating grains from their stalks by beating the stalks.

Threshing. A farmer holds a bundle of harvested wheat stalks and swings it down hard onto a wooden log. The ears at the ends of the stalks hit the log, and the grains are knocked loose and fall to the ground.Swing down hardBundle ofwheat stalksEars full of grainLoose grains fall to the ground
Figure 2. Threshing by hand: beating the stalks on a log knocks the grains loose.
  • A farmer may hold a bundle of stalks and beat it hard on a wooden log or a stone (Figure 2).
  • Bullocks may be made to walk round and round over stalks spread on the ground.
  • Today, many farmers use a machine called a thresher. It beats the stalks and blows away the husk at the same time. So it does threshing and winnowing together.

Remember

  • Handpicking uses differences in size, colour and shape.
  • Handpicking suits mixtures with only a few large, easy-to-see unwanted pieces.
  • Threshing: beating stalks to free the grains. A thresher also winnows.
Quick checkWhy is handpicking not used to separate sand from salt?Show answer

The grains of sand and salt are tiny, and there are far too many of them to pick out by hand. We need other methods: dissolve the salt in water, filter, then evaporate.

3Winnowing and sieving

Winnowing

After threshing, the grain is still mixed with light, dry husk, the papery cover of each grain. A farmer stands on a raised spot and fills a bamboo tray called a soop. Then she lets the mixture fall slowly while the wind blows.

Winnowing. A woman holds a winnowing tray of grain and husk high above her head and tips it. The heavier grains fall straight down into a heap below the tray. The wind carries the lighter husk to one side, where it forms a separate heap.WindGrainsheavy, fall downHusklight, blown asideSoop (winnowing tray)
Figure 3. Winnowing: the wind carries the light husk away, while the heavy grains fall straight down.

Winnowing

Winnowing separates the heavier and lighter parts of a mixture with the help of wind or blowing air.

The heavy grains drop almost straight down and form a heap. The wind pushes the light husk sideways. So the husk forms a separate heap a little further away. If there is no wind, a fan can be used.

You can try this with a handful of roasted peanuts. Rub them between your palms to loosen their thin red skins. Then blow gently over them on a plate. The skins fly off, and the nuts stay.

Sieving

Flour often has some bran in it, the outer coat of the wheat grain. It may also have a tiny stone or two. Shaking the flour through a sieve gives fine, smooth flour.

Sieving. Flour mixed with bran and small stones is shaken in a sieve held in two hands. The fine flour falls through the small holes of the wire mesh into a plate below. The larger bran and stones stay on top of the sieve.SieveBran and smallstones stay on topFine flour fallsthrough the holesPlate of sifted flour
Figure 4. Sieving: small particles pass through the holes; larger ones stay on top.

Sieving

Sieving separates the solids of a mixture by the size of their particles (tiny pieces). Particles smaller than the holes of the sieve pass through. Bigger ones are left behind.

So the holes of the sieve must be smaller than the particles we want to hold back. At a building site, workers throw sand against a large, slanted wire sieve. The sand passes through, and the pebbles and stones are kept out.

Remember

  • Winnowing separates heavy and light solids using wind or blown air.
  • Sieving separates solids whose particles are of different sizes.
  • The holes of a sieve must be smaller than the particles we want to keep back.
Quick checkWhy would winnowing not work in a closed room with no fan?Show answer

Winnowing needs moving air to carry the light husk away. In a closed room with no breeze or fan, the husk would fall down along with the grains.

4Evaporation

Stir a spoonful of salt into a glass of water. The salt seems to disappear, but taste the water and you know it is still there. The salt has dissolved. Its particles have spread all through the water and are too small to see. Water with something dissolved in it is called a solution.

Handpicking, sieving and filtering cannot get the salt back. So how do we do it?

Evaporation

Evaporation is the change of a liquid into its vapour (its gas form). When a solution is left to evaporate, the liquid escapes into the air. The dissolved solid is left behind.

Evaporation. Left: sea water in a shallow pit under the sun; the water slowly dries up and white salt is left behind. Right: salt water in a china dish is heated over a flame; the water escapes as steam and salt is left in the dish.In the sunsea water in a shallow pitsalt leftSteamChina dishFlameBy heatingsalt is left in the dish
Figure 5. Two ways to get salt back from salt water: drying in the sun, and heating.

Salt from sea water

Sea water has a lot of salt dissolved in it. Here is how salt is made along the coast:

  1. Sea water is let into wide, shallow pits.
  2. Over many days, the sun and the wind dry up the water.
  3. A layer of salt is left behind. It is collected and cleaned to give the salt we eat.

Why shallow pits? A wide, open surface dries much faster. Salt is also made from salty lakes, such as the Sambhar Lake in Rajasthan.

Salt has a special place in India’s freedom struggle. The British rulers had put a tax on salt. In 1930, Mahatma Gandhi walked from the Sabarmati Ashram to Dandi, on the Gujarat coast, to protest. There he made salt from sea water. This is the famous Dandi March, or Salt Satyagraha.

Seeing it for yourself

  • Brush some strong salt water onto a sheet of black paper and leave it in the sun. When it dries, white patches of salt appear.
  • Your teacher can heat salt water in a china dish over a flame. The water boils away as steam, and white salt is left in the dish. Heating makes water evaporate much faster than the sun does.

Never heat anything yourself without your teacher. Hot salt can crackle and jump out of the dish.

Evaporation is also used in Ayurveda. Many herbs are dried in the shade, so that their water evaporates. The useful part is kept for making medicines.

Remember

  • Evaporation turns a liquid into vapour and leaves the dissolved solid behind.
  • Salt is made from sea water in shallow pits, by the sun and wind.
  • Heating makes evaporation faster.
Quick checkWhy are salt pits made wide and shallow instead of narrow and deep?Show answer

A wide, shallow pit gives the water a large surface open to the sun and air. So the water evaporates much faster.

5Sedimentation and decantation

Stir some soil into a glass of water and leave it alone for a while. Slowly the soil sinks and settles at the bottom. The water above becomes clearer.

Soil is insoluble in water: it does not dissolve. Its heavy bits sink instead.

Sedimentation

Sedimentation is the settling of heavy, insoluble particles at the bottom of a liquid when it is left still. The settled layer is called the sediment.

Decantation

Decantation is gently pouring off the liquid by tilting the vessel, without stirring up the sediment.

Sedimentation and decantation. Left: muddy water left still in a beaker; the heavy mud has settled at the bottom as sediment, with clearer water above it. Right: a hand tilts the beaker gently so the clear water pours into another beaker while the sediment stays behind.Clear waterSediment1. Sedimentation2. Decantation
Figure 6. First let the solid settle (sedimentation), then pour off the liquid (decantation).

The two methods are usually used one after the other. Some everyday examples:

  • When rice or dal is washed, the grains sink. The dirty water above is poured away.
  • After tea is boiled, the tea leaves settle at the bottom of the pan. The tea can then be poured into a cup.
  • When muddy water is kept in a bucket, the mud settles. The clearer water can then be poured off.

Two liquids that do not mix

Oil and water do not mix. If you leave them in a glass, the oil forms a separate layer on top of the water. You can carefully pour off the oil, or let the water out from below. So decantation can also separate two liquids that do not mix.

A limitation

Decantation does not separate things completely. A little of the sediment often slips out with the liquid. You may still find a few tea leaves in your cup! For a cleaner result, the liquid is filtered.

Remember

  • Sedimentation: heavy, insoluble particles settle down.
  • Decantation: the liquid above is poured off gently.
  • Decantation is quick but not complete; filtration does a better job.
Quick checkWhy does the water have to be left still before decanting it?Show answer

The heavy particles need time to settle at the bottom. If the water is stirred or shaken, they mix up again and pour out with the water.

6Filtration

A tea strainer has a fine net with tiny holes. Tea passes through, but the tea leaves cannot. This is filtration.

Filtration

Filtration separates an insoluble solid from a liquid. The mixture is passed through a filter, a material with very small holes called pores.

The solid left on the filter is called the residue. The clear liquid that passes through is called the filtrate.

Filtering muddy water in the laboratory

Filtration. A folded filter paper cone sits inside a glass funnel held by a stand over a conical flask. Muddy water is poured into the paper. The mud cannot pass through the tiny pores and stays on the paper as the residue. Clear water drips through the funnel into the flask; this is the filtrate.Filter paperMuddy waterResidue (mud)FunnelFiltrate(clear water)Conicalflask
Figure 7. Filtering muddy water with a funnel and filter paper.
  1. Fold a round filter paper in half, and then in half again. Open one side to make a cone.
  2. Fit the cone into a funnel. Wet it a little so that it sticks to the funnel.
  3. Place the funnel in the mouth of a flask. Slowly pour the muddy water into the cone.
  4. The mud stays on the paper (residue). Clear water collects in the flask (filtrate).

Choosing a filter

The pores of the filter must be smaller than the particles we want to remove. That is why we choose different filters for different jobs.

FilterSize of poresUsed for
Tea strainer, fishing netLargeTea leaves from tea; fish from water
Cloth (such as muslin)SmallStraining paneer, juice or water; used since ancient times
Filter paperVery fineFine mud or chalk powder from water
Layers of sand, charcoal and cottonFineCleaning water in home and town water filters

A fishing net is also a filter. Water drains out through the gaps, but the fish are held back. Sadly, fishers often find plastic waste caught in their nets too.

Tea bags are filters as well. The first tea bags were made of silk. Later, gauze and muslin cloth were used. Now most are made of a kind of filter paper.

Make your own water filter

  1. Cut the bottom off a plastic bottle and turn it upside down.
  2. Plug the neck with cotton.
  3. Add layers of charcoal, then fine sand, then small pebbles.
  4. Pour muddy water in at the top. Collect the clearer water at the neck.

Remember: water that looks clear may still have germs. Boil it before drinking.

Remember

  • Filtration separates an insoluble solid from a liquid.
  • Residue stays on the filter; filtrate passes through.
  • The pore size of the filter decides what it can hold back.
Quick checkCan filtration separate salt from salt water? Why or why not?Show answer

No. The salt is dissolved. Its particles are tiny and spread all through the water, so they pass through the pores along with the water. Evaporation is needed.

7Churning and magnetic separation

Churning

In many homes, butter is made by churning curd with a wooden churner (mathani) or in a mixer. After some time, lumps of butter appear and float to the top. They are lifted out. The liquid left behind is buttermilk (chhachh).

Churning

Churning is stirring or spinning a liquid fast to separate its lighter part from its heavier part. Churning curd gives butter, which is lighter and floats, and buttermilk.

Dairies separate cream from milk in the same way. They spin the milk very fast in a machine. Both parts we get are useful, so this is an example of getting two useful parts.

Magnetic separation

A carpenter’s floor is full of sawdust mixed with small iron nails. Picking the nails out by hand would take ages. Instead, the carpenter moves a magnet over the sawdust. The nails jump up and stick to it.

Magnetic separation. A bar magnet is moved over a heap of sawdust mixed with iron nails. The nails cling to the magnet and are lifted out; the sawdust, which is not attracted by the magnet, stays behind.NSMagnetIron nailsSawdust
Figure 8. A magnet pulls iron nails out of sawdust.

Magnetic separation

Magnetic separation uses a magnet to pull out the parts that a magnet attracts, such as iron. The other parts stay behind.

In scrapyards and recycling plants, huge magnets hang from cranes. They lift iron scrap out of heaps of waste. The iron can then be melted and used again.

This method works only when one component is magnetic, which means a magnet pulls it. Iron, nickel and cobalt are magnetic. The other component must not be. A magnet cannot separate sand from sawdust.

Remember

  • Churning separates butter (lighter) from buttermilk.
  • A magnet separates iron and other magnetic materials from non-magnetic ones.
  • Large magnets are used to recover scrap iron for recycling.
Quick checkA packet of iron pins has spilled into a tray of sand. What is the quickest way to recover the pins?Show answer

Move a magnet through the sand. The iron pins stick to the magnet, and the sand is left behind.

8Choosing the right method

To choose a method, ask two questions.

  1. What kind of mixture is it? Is it a solid with a solid, a solid with a liquid, or two liquids?
  2. How are the components different?

The two flowcharts below help you answer them. Start at the top and follow the arrows.

Flowchart for two solids mixed together. Ask how they are different. If one is pulled by a magnet, such as iron nails in sawdust, use a magnet. If one is much lighter, such as husk with grain, use winnowing. If the pieces differ in size, such as pebbles in sand, use sieving. If a few pieces look different, such as stones in rice, use handpicking.Two solids mixed: how are they different?One is pulled by a magnete.g. iron nails in sawdustUse a magnetOne is much lightere.g. husk with grainWinnowingThe pieces differ in sizee.g. pebbles in sandSievingA few pieces look differente.g. stones in riceHandpicking
Figure 9. Two solids mixed together: pick the method that uses their difference.
Flowchart for a solid mixed with a liquid. Has the solid dissolved? If yes, use evaporation, as for salt from sea water. If no, does it settle quickly? If yes, use sedimentation, then decantation. If no, use filtration, as for chalk from water. Below: two liquids that do not mix, such as oil and water, are separated by decantation.A solid mixed with a liquidHas the solid dissolved?YesEvaporationsalt from sea waterNoDoes it settle quickly?YesSedimentation,then decantationNoFiltrationchalk from waterTwo liquids that do not mixDecantationoil from water
Figure 10. A solid in a liquid, or two liquids: follow the questions to a method.

The table puts all the methods together.

MethodMixture and difference usedExample
HandpickingSolids: size, colour or shape; few unwanted piecesStones from rice
ThreshingGrains come loose when stalks are beatenWheat grains from stalks
WinnowingSolids: one heavy, one lightHusk from grain
SievingSolids: particles of different sizesBran from flour, pebbles from sand
EvaporationSolid dissolved in a liquid: the liquid turns to vapourSalt from sea water
Sedimentation and decantationHeavy insoluble solid settles, or two liquids do not mixWashing rice; oil from water
FiltrationInsoluble solid too big to pass the pores of a filterMud from water
ChurningButter is lighter and floatsButter from curd
Magnetic separationOnly one solid is attracted by a magnetIron nails from sawdust

Using more than one method

Many mixtures need two or more methods, one after another. For example, here is how to separate a mixture of sand and salt:

  1. Add water and stir. The salt dissolves; the sand does not.
  2. Filter the mixture. Sand stays on the filter paper as the residue.
  3. Evaporate the filtrate (salt water). Salt is left behind.

Grain from the field goes through several steps too. First threshing, then winnowing, and then handpicking or sieving at home.

Remember

  • Ask: what kind of mixture is it, and how are the components different?
  • Some mixtures need several methods one after another.
  • Sand and salt: dissolve, filter, evaporate.
Quick checkHow would you separate a mixture of iron filings, sand and salt?Show answer

First use a magnet to remove the iron filings. Then add water to the sand and salt and stir, so the salt dissolves. Filter to get the sand back. Then evaporate the filtrate to get the salt.

Try it yourselfLook at everyday mixtures and pick the right way to separate them, put the steps in order, and spot the difference each method uses, in the Separation challenge.
Test yourselfTake the 16-question practice quiz on this chapter.